{
 "seed": 1109872877,
 "note": "Views beside the registered result. Intervals: the rule of summary_figures.interval, 10,000 resamples of questions, seeded with the study's seed. Values are unrounded.",
 "registered": {
  "google_aio": {
   "answers": 47,
   "median": 0.8214285714285714,
   "interval_95": [
    0.7222222222222222,
    0.9230769230769231
   ]
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "answers": 47,
   "median": 0.5454545454545454,
   "interval_95": [
    0.4,
    0.6923076923076923
   ]
  },
  "gemini": {
   "answers": 50,
   "median": 0.7321428571428572,
   "interval_95": [
    0.6583333333333333,
    0.8333333333333334
   ]
  }
 },
 "common_questions": {
  "questions": 44,
  "google_aio": {
   "answers": 44,
   "median": 0.8273809523809523,
   "interval_95": [
    0.72953216374269,
    0.9230769230769231
   ]
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "answers": 44,
   "median": 0.5477272727272727,
   "interval_95": [
    0.4,
    0.6923076923076923
   ]
  },
  "gemini": {
   "answers": 44,
   "median": 0.7071428571428571,
   "interval_95": [
    0.65,
    0.8545454545454545
   ]
  },
  "intervals_of_google_aio_and_chatgpt": "do not overlap"
 },
 "citing_answers": {
  "google_aio": {
   "answers": 46,
   "median": 0.8273809523809523,
   "interval_95": [
    0.7368421052631579,
    0.9230769230769231
   ],
   "answers_with_figures_that_cite_no_page": [
    "ELC-16"
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 507,
    "of": 625,
    "share": 0.8112
   }
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "answers": 43,
   "median": 0.5714285714285714,
   "interval_95": [
    0.4166666666666667,
    0.75
   ],
   "answers_with_figures_that_cite_no_page": [
    "SVC-06",
    "SVC-09",
    "SVC-10",
    "TRV-08"
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 267,
    "of": 442,
    "share": 0.6040723981900452
   }
  },
  "gemini": {
   "answers": 49,
   "median": 0.75,
   "interval_95": [
    0.6666666666666666,
    0.8666666666666667
   ],
   "answers_with_figures_that_cite_no_page": [
    "ELC-13"
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 453,
    "of": 651,
    "share": 0.695852534562212
   }
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "answers": 47,
   "median": 0.9365079365079365,
   "interval_95": [
    0.8636363636363636,
    1.0
   ],
   "answers_with_figures_that_cite_no_page": [],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 644,
    "of": 755,
    "share": 0.8529801324503311
   }
  },
  "claude": {
   "answers": 48,
   "median": 0.9375,
   "interval_95": [
    0.8918128654970761,
    1.0
   ],
   "answers_with_figures_that_cite_no_page": [
    "TRV-08",
    "TRV-16"
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 822,
    "of": 926,
    "share": 0.8876889848812095
   }
  }
 },
 "common_citing_questions": {
  "questions": 38,
  "google_aio": {
   "answers": 38,
   "median": 0.8257575757575758,
   "interval_95": [
    0.7222222222222222,
    0.9270833333333333
   ]
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "answers": 38,
   "median": 0.5714285714285714,
   "interval_95": [
    0.43478260869565216,
    0.7552447552447552
   ]
  },
  "gemini": {
   "answers": 38,
   "median": 0.7321428571428572,
   "interval_95": [
    0.6666666666666666,
    0.910427807486631
   ]
  },
  "intervals_of_google_aio_and_chatgpt": "overlap"
 },
 "units_common_questions": {
  "questions": 39,
  "ids": [
   "AIT-03",
   "AIT-04",
   "AIT-05",
   "AIT-06",
   "AIT-10",
   "AIT-16",
   "BIZ-01",
   "BIZ-02",
   "BIZ-05",
   "BIZ-06",
   "BIZ-07",
   "BIZ-08",
   "BIZ-13",
   "ELC-03",
   "ELC-09",
   "ELC-10",
   "ELC-12",
   "ELC-13",
   "ELC-14",
   "ELC-16",
   "FIN-01",
   "FIN-02",
   "FIN-05",
   "FIN-06",
   "FIN-14",
   "FIN-15",
   "FIN-17",
   "SVC-01",
   "SVC-06",
   "SVC-08",
   "SVC-09",
   "SVC-10",
   "SVC-15",
   "SVC-17",
   "TRV-06",
   "TRV-09",
   "TRV-11",
   "TRV-14",
   "TRV-15"
  ],
  "google_aio": {
   "answers": 39,
   "median": 0.8,
   "interval_95": [
    0.6666666666666666,
    0.9090909090909091
   ]
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "answers": 39,
   "median": 0.5,
   "interval_95": [
    0.2727272727272727,
    0.6666666666666666
   ]
  },
  "gemini": {
   "answers": 39,
   "median": 0.7,
   "interval_95": [
    0.4666666666666667,
    0.9
   ]
  },
  "intervals_of_google_aio_and_chatgpt": "meet at one value"
 },
 "paired": {
  "first": "google_aio",
  "second": "chatgpt",
  "sets": {
   "common_questions": {
    "questions": 44,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.8273809523809523,
    "second_median": 0.5477272727272727,
    "difference": 0.2796536796536796,
    "interval_95": [
     0.13598901098901095,
     0.46338826554464707
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 30,
     "of": 44,
     "share": 0.6818181818181818
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 7,
     "of": 44,
     "share": 0.1590909090909091
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 7,
     "of": 44,
     "share": 0.1590909090909091
    }
   },
   "both_answers_cite_a_page": {
    "questions": 39,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.8214285714285714,
    "second_median": 0.5714285714285714,
    "difference": 0.25,
    "interval_95": [
     0.0625,
     0.4
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 26,
     "of": 39,
     "share": 0.6666666666666666
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 6,
     "of": 39,
     "share": 0.15384615384615385
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 7,
     "of": 39,
     "share": 0.1794871794871795
    }
   },
   "unit_bearing_figures": {
    "questions": 39,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.8,
    "second_median": 0.5,
    "difference": 0.30000000000000004,
    "interval_95": [
     0.13636363636363635,
     0.475
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 24,
     "of": 39,
     "share": 0.6153846153846154
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 7,
     "of": 39,
     "share": 0.1794871794871795
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 8,
     "of": 39,
     "share": 0.20512820512820512
    }
   },
   "both_answers_have_two_or_more_readable_pages": {
    "questions": 20,
    "statistic": "mean of the per-question differences",
    "first_median": 0.880184331797235,
    "second_median": 0.7638888888888888,
    "difference": 0.15170040941604757,
    "interval_95": [
     0.058958402708402705,
     0.2516564919808258
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 12,
     "of": 20,
     "share": 0.6
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 20,
     "share": 0.1
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 6,
     "of": 20,
     "share": 0.3
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "pages_per_answer": {
  "google_aio": {
   "answers": 47,
   "median_cited_pages": 7,
   "median_readable_pages": 6,
   "figure_page_pairs": {
    "n": 1617,
    "of": 4235,
    "share": 0.38181818181818183
   },
   "mean_share_of_readable_pages_holding_a_figure": 0.4154035264674055
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "answers": 47,
   "median_cited_pages": 2,
   "median_readable_pages": 1,
   "figure_page_pairs": {
    "n": 367,
    "of": 832,
    "share": 0.4411057692307692
   },
   "mean_share_of_readable_pages_holding_a_figure": 0.4233333333333334
  },
  "gemini": {
   "answers": 50,
   "median_cited_pages": 3.0,
   "median_readable_pages": 2.0,
   "figure_page_pairs": {
    "n": 876,
    "of": 1671,
    "share": 0.5242369838420108
   },
   "mean_share_of_readable_pages_holding_a_figure": 0.5047402924861317
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "answers": 47,
   "median_cited_pages": 10,
   "median_readable_pages": 9,
   "figure_page_pairs": {
    "n": 3436,
    "of": 7613,
    "share": 0.45133324576382505
   },
   "mean_share_of_readable_pages_holding_a_figure": 0.43584840398747654
  },
  "claude": {
   "answers": 50,
   "median_cited_pages": 6.0,
   "median_readable_pages": 5.0,
   "figure_page_pairs": {
    "n": 2280,
    "of": 4576,
    "share": 0.4982517482517482
   },
   "mean_share_of_readable_pages_holding_a_figure": 0.49712713626451493
  }
 },
 "cut_to_k_pages": {
  "1": {
   "google_aio": {
    "expected_found": 265.85825693913955,
    "figures": 640,
    "pooled_share": 0.4154035264674055,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.34134615384615385,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 1,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.02127659574468085
    }
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "expected_found": 198.9666666666667,
    "figures": 470,
    "pooled_share": 0.4233333333333334,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.33333333333333337,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 6,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.1276595744680851
    }
   },
   "gemini": {
    "expected_found": 333.6333333333331,
    "figures": 661,
    "pooled_share": 0.5047402924861317,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.5,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 4,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.08
    }
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "expected_found": 329.0655450105448,
    "figures": 755,
    "pooled_share": 0.43584840398747654,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.42352941176470593,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.0
    }
   },
   "claude": {
    "expected_found": 466.8023809523795,
    "figures": 939,
    "pooled_share": 0.49712713626451493,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.47348484848484845,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.04
    }
   }
  },
  "2": {
   "google_aio": {
    "expected_found": 366.20170189287836,
    "figures": 640,
    "pooled_share": 0.5721901592076224,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.5388257575757576,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 1,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.02127659574468085
    }
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "expected_found": 254.9333333333332,
    "figures": 470,
    "pooled_share": 0.5424113475177302,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.48000000000000015,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 25,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.5319148936170213
    }
   },
   "gemini": {
    "expected_found": 413.7,
    "figures": 661,
    "pooled_share": 0.6258698940998487,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.6583333333333332,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 12,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.24
    }
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "expected_found": 448.86024975025015,
    "figures": 755,
    "pooled_share": 0.594516887086424,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.6018518518518517,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.0
    }
   },
   "claude": {
    "expected_found": 628.0761904761896,
    "figures": 939,
    "pooled_share": 0.6688777321365171,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.7065656565656566,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.04
    }
   }
  },
  "3": {
   "google_aio": {
    "expected_found": 417.9942195059842,
    "figures": 640,
    "pooled_share": 0.6531159679781002,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.6666666666666666,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 6,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.1276595744680851
    }
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "expected_found": 264.0,
    "figures": 470,
    "pooled_share": 0.5617021276595745,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.5454545454545454,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 39,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.8297872340425532
    }
   },
   "gemini": {
    "expected_found": 444.64999999999986,
    "figures": 661,
    "pooled_share": 0.6726928895612706,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.7304761904761905,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 29,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.58
    }
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "expected_found": 510.4336420177845,
    "figures": 755,
    "pooled_share": 0.6760710490301781,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.6946941946941949,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 1,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.02127659574468085
    }
   },
   "claude": {
    "expected_found": 715.2785714285711,
    "figures": 939,
    "pooled_share": 0.7617450174958159,
    "median_share_per_answer": 0.829375,
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "n": 4,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.08
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "exactly_two_pages": {
  "google_aio": {
   "answers": 5,
   "n": 39,
   "of": 55,
   "share": 0.7090909090909091
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "answers": 14,
   "n": 117,
   "of": 165,
   "share": 0.7090909090909091
  },
  "gemini": {
   "answers": 17,
   "n": 143,
   "of": 193,
   "share": 0.7409326424870466
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "answers": 1,
   "n": 2,
   "of": 10,
   "share": 0.2
  },
  "claude": {
   "answers": 2,
   "n": 44,
   "of": 51,
   "share": 0.8627450980392157
  }
 },
 "share_by_readable_pages": {
  "google_aio": {
   "0": {
    "answers": 1,
    "n": 0,
    "of": 15,
    "share": 0.0
   },
   "1": {
    "answers": 0,
    "n": 0,
    "of": 0,
    "share": null
   },
   "2": {
    "answers": 5,
    "n": 39,
    "of": 55,
    "share": 0.7090909090909091
   },
   "3 or more": {
    "answers": 41,
    "n": 468,
    "of": 570,
    "share": 0.8210526315789474
   },
   "answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
    "n": 1,
    "of": 47,
    "share": 0.02127659574468085
   },
   "found_in_answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
    "answers": 1,
    "n": 0,
    "of": 15,
    "share": 0.0
   },
   "at_most_one_readable_page_and_an_unreadable_cited_page": {
    "n": 0,
    "of": 1,
    "share": null
   }
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "0": {
    "answers": 6,
    "n": 0,
    "of": 37,
    "share": 0.0
   },
   "1": {
    "answers": 19,
    "n": 81,
    "of": 171,
    "share": 0.47368421052631576
   },
   "2": {
    "answers": 14,
    "n": 117,
    "of": 165,
    "share": 0.7090909090909091
   },
   "3 or more": {
    "answers": 8,
    "n": 69,
    "of": 97,
    "share": 0.711340206185567
   },
   "answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
    "n": 25,
    "of": 47,
    "share": 0.5319148936170213
   },
   "found_in_answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
    "answers": 25,
    "n": 81,
    "of": 208,
    "share": 0.3894230769230769
   },
   "at_most_one_readable_page_and_an_unreadable_cited_page": {
    "n": 9,
    "of": 25,
    "share": 0.36
   }
  },
  "gemini": {
   "0": {
    "answers": 4,
    "n": 0,
    "of": 35,
    "share": 0.0
   },
   "1": {
    "answers": 8,
    "n": 43,
    "of": 85,
    "share": 0.5058823529411764
   },
   "2": {
    "answers": 17,
    "n": 143,
    "of": 193,
    "share": 0.7409326424870466
   },
   "3 or more": {
    "answers": 21,
    "n": 267,
    "of": 348,
    "share": 0.7672413793103449
   },
   "answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
    "n": 12,
    "of": 50,
    "share": 0.24
   },
   "found_in_answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
    "answers": 12,
    "n": 43,
    "of": 120,
    "share": 0.35833333333333334
   },
   "at_most_one_readable_page_and_an_unreadable_cited_page": {
    "n": 5,
    "of": 12,
    "share": 0.4166666666666667
   }
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "0": {
    "answers": 0,
    "n": 0,
    "of": 0,
    "share": null
   },
   "1": {
    "answers": 0,
    "n": 0,
    "of": 0,
    "share": null
   },
   "2": {
    "answers": 1,
    "n": 2,
    "of": 10,
    "share": 0.2
   },
   "3 or more": {
    "answers": 46,
    "n": 642,
    "of": 745,
    "share": 0.8617449664429531
   },
   "answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
    "n": 0,
    "of": 47,
    "share": 0.0
   },
   "found_in_answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
    "answers": 0,
    "n": 0,
    "of": 0,
    "share": null
   },
   "at_most_one_readable_page_and_an_unreadable_cited_page": {
    "n": 0,
    "of": 0,
    "share": null
   }
  },
  "claude": {
   "0": {
    "answers": 2,
    "n": 0,
    "of": 13,
    "share": 0.0
   },
   "1": {
    "answers": 0,
    "n": 0,
    "of": 0,
    "share": null
   },
   "2": {
    "answers": 2,
    "n": 44,
    "of": 51,
    "share": 0.8627450980392157
   },
   "3 or more": {
    "answers": 46,
    "n": 778,
    "of": 875,
    "share": 0.8891428571428571
   },
   "answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
    "n": 2,
    "of": 50,
    "share": 0.04
   },
   "found_in_answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
    "answers": 2,
    "n": 0,
    "of": 13,
    "share": 0.0
   },
   "at_most_one_readable_page_and_an_unreadable_cited_page": {
    "n": 0,
    "of": 2,
    "share": null
   }
  }
 },
 "share_by_page_band": {
  "cited_pages": {
   "google_aio": {
    "0": {
     "answers": 1,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 15,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "1": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    },
    "2": {
     "answers": 1,
     "n": 9,
     "of": 11,
     "share": 0.8181818181818182
    },
    "3 to 4": {
     "answers": 9,
     "n": 123,
     "of": 145,
     "share": 0.8482758620689655
    },
    "5 to 7": {
     "answers": 16,
     "n": 155,
     "of": 192,
     "share": 0.8072916666666666
    },
    "8 or more": {
     "answers": 20,
     "n": 220,
     "of": 277,
     "share": 0.7942238267148014
    }
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "0": {
     "answers": 4,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 28,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "1": {
     "answers": 14,
     "n": 57,
     "of": 118,
     "share": 0.4830508474576271
    },
    "2": {
     "answers": 18,
     "n": 120,
     "of": 188,
     "share": 0.6382978723404256
    },
    "3 to 4": {
     "answers": 9,
     "n": 70,
     "of": 110,
     "share": 0.6363636363636364
    },
    "5 to 7": {
     "answers": 2,
     "n": 20,
     "of": 26,
     "share": 0.7692307692307693
    },
    "8 or more": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    }
   },
   "gemini": {
    "0": {
     "answers": 1,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "1": {
     "answers": 7,
     "n": 37,
     "of": 82,
     "share": 0.45121951219512196
    },
    "2": {
     "answers": 14,
     "n": 105,
     "of": 157,
     "share": 0.6687898089171974
    },
    "3 to 4": {
     "answers": 24,
     "n": 264,
     "of": 362,
     "share": 0.7292817679558011
    },
    "5 to 7": {
     "answers": 4,
     "n": 47,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.94
    },
    "8 or more": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    }
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "0": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    },
    "1": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    },
    "2": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    },
    "3 to 4": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    },
    "5 to 7": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    },
    "8 or more": {
     "answers": 47,
     "n": 644,
     "of": 755,
     "share": 0.8529801324503311
    }
   },
   "claude": {
    "0": {
     "answers": 2,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 13,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "1": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    },
    "2": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    },
    "3 to 4": {
     "answers": 9,
     "n": 118,
     "of": 130,
     "share": 0.9076923076923077
    },
    "5 to 7": {
     "answers": 37,
     "n": 682,
     "of": 772,
     "share": 0.883419689119171
    },
    "8 or more": {
     "answers": 2,
     "n": 22,
     "of": 24,
     "share": 0.9166666666666666
    }
   }
  },
  "readable_pages": {
   "google_aio": {
    "0": {
     "answers": 1,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 15,
     "share": 0.0,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    },
    "1": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    },
    "2": {
     "answers": 5,
     "n": 39,
     "of": 55,
     "share": 0.7090909090909091,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 62,
      "of": 110,
      "share": 0.5636363636363636
     }
    },
    "3 to 4": {
     "answers": 9,
     "n": 112,
     "of": 131,
     "share": 0.8549618320610687,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 280,
      "of": 498,
      "share": 0.5622489959839357
     }
    },
    "5 to 7": {
     "answers": 18,
     "n": 183,
     "of": 230,
     "share": 0.7956521739130434,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 591,
      "of": 1467,
      "share": 0.40286298568507156
     }
    },
    "8 or more": {
     "answers": 14,
     "n": 173,
     "of": 209,
     "share": 0.8277511961722488,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 684,
      "of": 2160,
      "share": 0.31666666666666665
     }
    }
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "0": {
     "answers": 6,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 37,
     "share": 0.0,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    },
    "1": {
     "answers": 19,
     "n": 81,
     "of": 171,
     "share": 0.47368421052631576,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 81,
      "of": 171,
      "share": 0.47368421052631576
     }
    },
    "2": {
     "answers": 14,
     "n": 117,
     "of": 165,
     "share": 0.7090909090909091,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 159,
      "of": 330,
      "share": 0.4818181818181818
     }
    },
    "3 to 4": {
     "answers": 7,
     "n": 54,
     "of": 77,
     "share": 0.7012987012987013,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 98,
      "of": 231,
      "share": 0.42424242424242425
     }
    },
    "5 to 7": {
     "answers": 1,
     "n": 15,
     "of": 20,
     "share": 0.75,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 29,
      "of": 100,
      "share": 0.29
     }
    },
    "8 or more": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    }
   },
   "gemini": {
    "0": {
     "answers": 4,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 35,
     "share": 0.0,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    },
    "1": {
     "answers": 8,
     "n": 43,
     "of": 85,
     "share": 0.5058823529411764,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 43,
      "of": 85,
      "share": 0.5058823529411764
     }
    },
    "2": {
     "answers": 17,
     "n": 143,
     "of": 193,
     "share": 0.7409326424870466,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 234,
      "of": 386,
      "share": 0.6062176165803109
     }
    },
    "3 to 4": {
     "answers": 18,
     "n": 232,
     "of": 310,
     "share": 0.7483870967741936,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 500,
      "of": 998,
      "share": 0.501002004008016
     }
    },
    "5 to 7": {
     "answers": 3,
     "n": 35,
     "of": 38,
     "share": 0.9210526315789473,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 99,
      "of": 202,
      "share": 0.4900990099009901
     }
    },
    "8 or more": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    }
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "0": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    },
    "1": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    },
    "2": {
     "answers": 1,
     "n": 2,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.2,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 3,
      "of": 20,
      "share": 0.15
     }
    },
    "3 to 4": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    },
    "5 to 7": {
     "answers": 9,
     "n": 89,
     "of": 105,
     "share": 0.8476190476190476,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 242,
      "of": 691,
      "share": 0.35021707670043417
     }
    },
    "8 or more": {
     "answers": 37,
     "n": 553,
     "of": 640,
     "share": 0.8640625,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 3191,
      "of": 6902,
      "share": 0.4623297594900029
     }
    }
   },
   "claude": {
    "0": {
     "answers": 2,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 13,
     "share": 0.0,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    },
    "1": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    },
    "2": {
     "answers": 2,
     "n": 44,
     "of": 51,
     "share": 0.8627450980392157,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 70,
      "of": 102,
      "share": 0.6862745098039216
     }
    },
    "3 to 4": {
     "answers": 16,
     "n": 221,
     "of": 265,
     "share": 0.8339622641509434,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 519,
      "of": 984,
      "share": 0.5274390243902439
     }
    },
    "5 to 7": {
     "answers": 30,
     "n": 557,
     "of": 610,
     "share": 0.9131147540983606,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 1691,
      "of": 3490,
      "share": 0.4845272206303725
     }
    },
    "8 or more": {
     "answers": 0,
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null,
     "figure_page_pairs": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 0,
      "share": null
     }
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "two_or_more_readable_pages": {
  "google_aio": {
   "answers": 46,
   "median": 0.8273809523809523,
   "interval_95": [
    0.7368421052631579,
    0.9230769230769231
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 507,
    "of": 625,
    "share": 0.8112
   }
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "answers": 22,
   "median": 0.7638888888888888,
   "interval_95": [
    0.5454545454545454,
    0.9
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 186,
    "of": 262,
    "share": 0.7099236641221374
   }
  },
  "gemini": {
   "answers": 38,
   "median": 0.7638888888888888,
   "interval_95": [
    0.7,
    0.9558823529411764
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 410,
    "of": 541,
    "share": 0.7578558225508318
   }
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "answers": 47,
   "median": 0.9365079365079365,
   "interval_95": [
    0.8636363636363636,
    1.0
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 644,
    "of": 755,
    "share": 0.8529801324503311
   }
  },
  "claude": {
   "answers": 48,
   "median": 0.9375,
   "interval_95": [
    0.8918128654970761,
    1.0
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 822,
    "of": 926,
    "share": 0.8876889848812095
   }
  }
 },
 "pages_and_share": {
  "cited_pages, answers with at least 1": {
   "google_aio": {
    "answers": 46,
    "rank_correlation": -0.09546515117153574,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.35440582457459163,
     0.18205673623493665
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "answers": 43,
    "rank_correlation": 0.2737790370543358,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.013337306485351655,
     0.5264510816532106
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "gemini": {
    "answers": 49,
    "rank_correlation": 0.37481158075307675,
    "interval_95": [
     0.09765138532975651,
     0.6115742898912356
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": false
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "answers": 47,
    "rank_correlation": 0.22119618966819618,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.04859711803426114,
     0.45284732465008265
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "claude": {
    "answers": 48,
    "rank_correlation": 0.13195376187154556,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.1433135126223037,
     0.3919061383245808
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   }
  },
  "cited_pages, answers with at least 2": {
   "google_aio": {
    "answers": 46,
    "rank_correlation": -0.09546515117153574,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.35440582457459163,
     0.18205673623493665
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "answers": 29,
    "rank_correlation": 0.1372129655735003,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.21737248503616377,
     0.4617944073577184
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "gemini": {
    "answers": 42,
    "rank_correlation": 0.25650911675852195,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.05667905192377405,
     0.539289625553465
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "answers": 47,
    "rank_correlation": 0.22119618966819618,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.04859711803426114,
     0.45284732465008265
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "claude": {
    "answers": 48,
    "rank_correlation": 0.13195376187154556,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.1433135126223037,
     0.3919061383245808
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   }
  },
  "readable_pages, answers with at least 1": {
   "google_aio": {
    "answers": 46,
    "rank_correlation": 0.03323156498355504,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.2466151311933692,
     0.3174169744203705
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "answers": 41,
    "rank_correlation": 0.34235834601456,
    "interval_95": [
     0.06079833308455367,
     0.582838547369614
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": false
   },
   "gemini": {
    "answers": 46,
    "rank_correlation": 0.3822978804340878,
    "interval_95": [
     0.09614407047068622,
     0.6195734179022111
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": false
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "answers": 47,
    "rank_correlation": 0.2324435681426757,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.0647448834793886,
     0.506715820975821
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "claude": {
    "answers": 48,
    "rank_correlation": 0.3305304888394723,
    "interval_95": [
     0.06600927337276719,
     0.5551303161056966
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": false
   }
  },
  "readable_pages, answers with at least 2": {
   "google_aio": {
    "answers": 46,
    "rank_correlation": 0.03323156498355504,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.2466151311933692,
     0.3174169744203705
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "answers": 22,
    "rank_correlation": 0.11095171738445694,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.30047236805254707,
     0.4945797856973991
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "gemini": {
    "answers": 38,
    "rank_correlation": 0.15415773749256975,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.16589520203667446,
     0.45571397630650246
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "answers": 47,
    "rank_correlation": 0.2324435681426757,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.0647448834793886,
     0.506715820975821
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": true
   },
   "claude": {
    "answers": 48,
    "rank_correlation": 0.3305304888394723,
    "interval_95": [
     0.06600927337276719,
     0.5551303161056966
    ],
    "resamples_used": 10000,
    "interval_includes_zero": false
   }
  },
  "citing_answers_by_cited_pages": {
   "google_aio": {
    "three_or_more": {
     "n": 45,
     "of": 46,
     "share": 0.9782608695652174
    },
    "one_or_two": {
     "n": 1,
     "of": 46,
     "share": 0.021739130434782608
    }
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "three_or_more": {
     "n": 11,
     "of": 43,
     "share": 0.2558139534883721
    },
    "one_or_two": {
     "n": 32,
     "of": 43,
     "share": 0.7441860465116279
    }
   },
   "gemini": {
    "three_or_more": {
     "n": 28,
     "of": 49,
     "share": 0.5714285714285714
    },
    "one_or_two": {
     "n": 21,
     "of": 49,
     "share": 0.42857142857142855
    }
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "three_or_more": {
     "n": 47,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 1.0
    },
    "one_or_two": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.0
    }
   },
   "claude": {
    "three_or_more": {
     "n": 48,
     "of": 48,
     "share": 1.0
    },
    "one_or_two": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 48,
     "share": 0.0
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "placebo": {
  "draws_per_answer": 1000,
  "seed": 1109872877,
  "pool": "The readable pages of the main set, without the pages that Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT or Gemini cite for a question of the answer's sector. The same pool for all five engines.",
  "pool_pages_by_sector": {
   "ai_tools": 343,
   "business_software": 327,
   "consumer_electronics": 352,
   "legal_local_services": 343,
   "personal_finance": 344,
   "travel": 341
  },
  "check_pairs_compared_with_the_frozen_match": 5313,
  "google_aio": {
   "all": {
    "figures": 640,
    "placebo_share": 0.28030468750000004,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2805732113954027,
    "actual": {
     "n": 507,
     "of": 640,
     "share": 0.7921875
    }
   },
   "number_only": {
    "figures": 166,
    "placebo_share": 0.5521867469879518,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.5524339784139652,
    "actual": {
     "n": 152,
     "of": 166,
     "share": 0.9156626506024096
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures": 473,
    "placebo_share": 0.1854799154334038,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.18575647965399483,
    "actual": {
     "n": 355,
     "of": 473,
     "share": 0.7505285412262156
    }
   },
   "by_sector": {
    "ai_tools": {
     "figures": 113,
     "placebo_share": 0.4172920353982301,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4184777436179273,
     "actual": {
      "n": 112,
      "of": 113,
      "share": 0.9911504424778761
     }
    },
    "business_software": {
     "figures": 90,
     "placebo_share": 0.23961111111111114,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.23837912027362307,
     "actual": {
      "n": 71,
      "of": 90,
      "share": 0.7888888888888889
     }
    },
    "consumer_electronics": {
     "figures": 89,
     "placebo_share": 0.22239325842696628,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.22394571825232845,
     "actual": {
      "n": 61,
      "of": 89,
      "share": 0.6853932584269663
     }
    },
    "legal_local_services": {
     "figures": 135,
     "placebo_share": 0.2096962962962963,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2107220939173492,
     "actual": {
      "n": 111,
      "of": 135,
      "share": 0.8222222222222222
     }
    },
    "personal_finance": {
     "figures": 122,
     "placebo_share": 0.16882786885245904,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.16998177907849937,
     "actual": {
      "n": 89,
      "of": 122,
      "share": 0.7295081967213115
     }
    },
    "travel": {
     "figures": 91,
     "placebo_share": 0.46128571428571424,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4583331954805446,
     "actual": {
      "n": 63,
      "of": 91,
      "share": 0.6923076923076923
     }
    }
   }
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "all": {
    "figures": 470,
    "placebo_share": 0.1798063829787234,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.18017133902375326,
    "actual": {
     "n": 267,
     "of": 470,
     "share": 0.5680851063829787
    }
   },
   "number_only": {
    "figures": 105,
    "placebo_share": 0.49618095238095233,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4967143735809169,
    "actual": {
     "n": 81,
     "of": 105,
     "share": 0.7714285714285715
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures": 365,
    "placebo_share": 0.08879452054794519,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.08911101401415847,
    "actual": {
     "n": 186,
     "of": 365,
     "share": 0.5095890410958904
    }
   },
   "by_sector": {
    "ai_tools": {
     "figures": 85,
     "placebo_share": 0.2574470588235294,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2570249375814385,
     "actual": {
      "n": 78,
      "of": 85,
      "share": 0.9176470588235294
     }
    },
    "business_software": {
     "figures": 92,
     "placebo_share": 0.16275,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.16270608953783935,
     "actual": {
      "n": 40,
      "of": 92,
      "share": 0.43478260869565216
     }
    },
    "consumer_electronics": {
     "figures": 89,
     "placebo_share": 0.19787640449438204,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.19904881687185058,
     "actual": {
      "n": 51,
      "of": 89,
      "share": 0.5730337078651685
     }
    },
    "legal_local_services": {
     "figures": 65,
     "placebo_share": 0.10490769230769231,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.10442001472804287,
     "actual": {
      "n": 25,
      "of": 65,
      "share": 0.38461538461538464
     }
    },
    "personal_finance": {
     "figures": 84,
     "placebo_share": 0.14344047619047617,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.14448991748757392,
     "actual": {
      "n": 55,
      "of": 84,
      "share": 0.6547619047619048
     }
    },
    "travel": {
     "figures": 55,
     "placebo_share": 0.20316363636363635,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.20408455784339868,
     "actual": {
      "n": 18,
      "of": 55,
      "share": 0.32727272727272727
     }
    }
   }
  },
  "gemini": {
   "all": {
    "figures": 661,
    "placebo_share": 0.20069742813918307,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.19924581354174808,
    "actual": {
     "n": 453,
     "of": 661,
     "share": 0.6853252647503782
    }
   },
   "number_only": {
    "figures": 181,
    "placebo_share": 0.4754309392265193,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.47400621360017314,
    "actual": {
     "n": 141,
     "of": 181,
     "share": 0.7790055248618785
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures": 475,
    "placebo_share": 0.09812210526315789,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.09664496439887184,
    "actual": {
     "n": 312,
     "of": 475,
     "share": 0.6568421052631579
    }
   },
   "by_sector": {
    "ai_tools": {
     "figures": 88,
     "placebo_share": 0.29725,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.29599275007123294,
     "actual": {
      "n": 87,
      "of": 88,
      "share": 0.9886363636363636
     }
    },
    "business_software": {
     "figures": 157,
     "placebo_share": 0.17381528662420384,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.17254616467567502,
     "actual": {
      "n": 118,
      "of": 157,
      "share": 0.7515923566878981
     }
    },
    "consumer_electronics": {
     "figures": 74,
     "placebo_share": 0.1230945945945946,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.12052242972371914,
     "actual": {
      "n": 32,
      "of": 74,
      "share": 0.43243243243243246
     }
    },
    "legal_local_services": {
     "figures": 150,
     "placebo_share": 0.20860666666666666,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2069968738141237,
     "actual": {
      "n": 106,
      "of": 150,
      "share": 0.7066666666666667
     }
    },
    "personal_finance": {
     "figures": 120,
     "placebo_share": 0.11245833333333333,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.11173986709628934,
     "actual": {
      "n": 65,
      "of": 120,
      "share": 0.5416666666666666
     }
    },
    "travel": {
     "figures": 72,
     "placebo_share": 0.35165277777777776,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.34982497177107685,
     "actual": {
      "n": 45,
      "of": 72,
      "share": 0.625
     }
    }
   }
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "all": {
    "figures": 755,
    "placebo_share": 0.4034927152317881,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4035048439834926,
    "actual": {
     "n": 644,
     "of": 755,
     "share": 0.8529801324503311
    }
   },
   "number_only": {
    "figures": 177,
    "placebo_share": 0.6586723163841808,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.6586796305075543,
    "actual": {
     "n": 177,
     "of": 177,
     "share": 1.0
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures": 576,
    "placebo_share": 0.32647916666666665,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.32649281702725735,
    "actual": {
     "n": 467,
     "of": 576,
     "share": 0.8107638888888888
    }
   },
   "by_sector": {
    "ai_tools": {
     "figures": 116,
     "placebo_share": 0.6112758620689656,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.6118035200748074,
     "actual": {
      "n": 115,
      "of": 116,
      "share": 0.9913793103448276
     }
    },
    "business_software": {
     "figures": 250,
     "placebo_share": 0.447056,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.44656682182172436,
     "actual": {
      "n": 200,
      "of": 250,
      "share": 0.8
     }
    },
    "consumer_electronics": {
     "figures": 117,
     "placebo_share": 0.3958290598290598,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.395562309395587,
     "actual": {
      "n": 107,
      "of": 117,
      "share": 0.9145299145299145
     }
    },
    "legal_local_services": {
     "figures": 105,
     "placebo_share": 0.1908952380952381,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.1919089728524547,
     "actual": {
      "n": 90,
      "of": 105,
      "share": 0.8571428571428571
     }
    },
    "personal_finance": {
     "figures": 98,
     "placebo_share": 0.2703163265306122,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.26987832366964715,
     "actual": {
      "n": 80,
      "of": 98,
      "share": 0.8163265306122449
     }
    },
    "travel": {
     "figures": 69,
     "placebo_share": 0.422,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4225497877537941,
     "actual": {
      "n": 52,
      "of": 69,
      "share": 0.7536231884057971
     }
    }
   }
  },
  "claude": {
   "all": {
    "figures": 939,
    "placebo_share": 0.23617358892438764,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2353422371950998,
    "actual": {
     "n": 822,
     "of": 939,
     "share": 0.8753993610223643
    }
   },
   "number_only": {
    "figures": 163,
    "placebo_share": 0.5393742331288344,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.5380903046943922,
    "actual": {
     "n": 144,
     "of": 163,
     "share": 0.8834355828220859
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures": 775,
    "placebo_share": 0.1727083870967742,
    "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.17197114975614547,
    "actual": {
     "n": 678,
     "of": 775,
     "share": 0.8748387096774194
    }
   },
   "by_sector": {
    "ai_tools": {
     "figures": 119,
     "placebo_share": 0.4495126050420168,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4484102085334683,
     "actual": {
      "n": 118,
      "of": 119,
      "share": 0.9915966386554622
     }
    },
    "business_software": {
     "figures": 240,
     "placebo_share": 0.26765416666666664,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2675840256178443,
     "actual": {
      "n": 229,
      "of": 240,
      "share": 0.9541666666666667
     }
    },
    "consumer_electronics": {
     "figures": 127,
     "placebo_share": 0.26912598425196854,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.26618926653038266,
     "actual": {
      "n": 104,
      "of": 127,
      "share": 0.8188976377952756
     }
    },
    "legal_local_services": {
     "figures": 182,
     "placebo_share": 0.15632967032967035,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.1568375770183339,
     "actual": {
      "n": 168,
      "of": 182,
      "share": 0.9230769230769231
     }
    },
    "personal_finance": {
     "figures": 162,
     "placebo_share": 0.09900617283950618,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.09681438951139884,
     "actual": {
      "n": 126,
      "of": 162,
      "share": 0.7777777777777778
     }
    },
    "travel": {
     "figures": 109,
     "placebo_share": 0.2327339449541284,
     "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.23276121830175636,
     "actual": {
      "n": 77,
      "of": 109,
      "share": 0.7064220183486238
     }
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "units": {
  "all_engines": {
   "figures_the_check_could_read": 1765,
   "number_only": {
    "n": 452,
    "of": 1765,
    "share": 0.25609065155807365
   },
   "found_figures_matched_on_the_number_alone": {
    "n": 374,
    "of": 1227,
    "share": 0.30480847595762023
   }
  },
  "five_engines": {
   "figures_the_check_could_read": 3456,
   "number_only": {
    "n": 792,
    "of": 3456,
    "share": 0.22916666666666666
   },
   "found_figures_matched_on_the_number_alone": {
    "n": 695,
    "of": 2693,
    "share": 0.2580764946156703
   }
  },
  "google_aio": {
   "with_unit": {
    "n": 355,
    "of": 473,
    "share": 0.7505285412262156
   },
   "number_only": {
    "n": 152,
    "of": 166,
    "share": 0.9156626506024096
   },
   "found_figures_matched_on_the_number_alone": {
    "n": 152,
    "of": 507,
    "share": 0.29980276134122286
   },
   "with_unit_per_answer": {
    "answers": 44,
    "median": 0.8,
    "interval_95": [
     0.6666666666666666,
     0.9090909090909091
    ]
   }
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "with_unit": {
    "n": 186,
    "of": 365,
    "share": 0.5095890410958904
   },
   "number_only": {
    "n": 81,
    "of": 105,
    "share": 0.7714285714285715
   },
   "found_figures_matched_on_the_number_alone": {
    "n": 81,
    "of": 267,
    "share": 0.30337078651685395
   },
   "with_unit_per_answer": {
    "answers": 41,
    "median": 0.5,
    "interval_95": [
     0.2727272727272727,
     0.6
    ]
   }
  },
  "gemini": {
   "with_unit": {
    "n": 312,
    "of": 475,
    "share": 0.6568421052631579
   },
   "number_only": {
    "n": 141,
    "of": 181,
    "share": 0.7790055248618785
   },
   "found_figures_matched_on_the_number_alone": {
    "n": 141,
    "of": 453,
    "share": 0.31125827814569534
   },
   "with_unit_per_answer": {
    "answers": 48,
    "median": 0.69375,
    "interval_95": [
     0.4666666666666667,
     0.9
    ]
   }
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "with_unit": {
    "n": 467,
    "of": 576,
    "share": 0.8107638888888888
   },
   "number_only": {
    "n": 177,
    "of": 177,
    "share": 1.0
   },
   "found_figures_matched_on_the_number_alone": {
    "n": 177,
    "of": 644,
    "share": 0.2748447204968944
   },
   "with_unit_per_answer": {
    "answers": 45,
    "median": 0.9166666666666666,
    "interval_95": [
     0.8333333333333334,
     1.0
    ]
   }
  },
  "claude": {
   "with_unit": {
    "n": 678,
    "of": 775,
    "share": 0.8748387096774194
   },
   "number_only": {
    "n": 144,
    "of": 163,
    "share": 0.8834355828220859
   },
   "found_figures_matched_on_the_number_alone": {
    "n": 144,
    "of": 822,
    "share": 0.17518248175182483
   },
   "with_unit_per_answer": {
    "answers": 47,
    "median": 0.9375,
    "interval_95": [
     0.8823529411764706,
     1.0
    ]
   }
  }
 },
 "attached": {
  "google_aio": {
   "available": true,
   "no_source_attached_to_the_sentence": {
    "n": 307,
    "of": 640,
    "share": 0.4796875
   },
   "the_same_in_answers_that_cite_a_page": {
    "n": 292,
    "of": 625,
    "share": 0.4672
   },
   "found_on_the_attached_source_where_one_is_attached": {
    "n": 202,
    "of": 333,
    "share": 0.6066066066066066
   },
   "found_elsewhere_with_no_source_attached": {
    "n": 242,
    "of": 305,
    "share": 0.7934426229508197
   }
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "available": true,
   "no_source_attached_to_the_sentence": {
    "n": 285,
    "of": 470,
    "share": 0.6063829787234043
   },
   "the_same_in_answers_that_cite_a_page": {
    "n": 257,
    "of": 442,
    "share": 0.581447963800905
   },
   "found_on_the_attached_source_where_one_is_attached": {
    "n": 127,
    "of": 185,
    "share": 0.6864864864864865
   },
   "found_elsewhere_with_no_source_attached": {
    "n": 130,
    "of": 140,
    "share": 0.9285714285714286
   }
  },
  "gemini": {
   "available": true,
   "no_source_attached_to_the_sentence": {
    "n": 291,
    "of": 661,
    "share": 0.4402420574886536
   },
   "the_same_in_answers_that_cite_a_page": {
    "n": 281,
    "of": 651,
    "share": 0.43164362519201227
   },
   "found_on_the_attached_source_where_one_is_attached": {
    "n": 281,
    "of": 370,
    "share": 0.7594594594594595
   },
   "found_elsewhere_with_no_source_attached": {
    "n": 142,
    "of": 172,
    "share": 0.8255813953488372
   }
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "available": false
  },
  "claude": {
   "available": true,
   "no_source_attached_to_the_sentence": {
    "n": 233,
    "of": 939,
    "share": 0.24813631522896698
   },
   "the_same_in_answers_that_cite_a_page": {
    "n": 220,
    "of": 926,
    "share": 0.23758099352051837
   },
   "found_on_the_attached_source_where_one_is_attached": {
    "n": 574,
    "of": 706,
    "share": 0.8130311614730878
   },
   "found_elsewhere_with_no_source_attached": {
    "n": 188,
    "of": 248,
    "share": 0.7580645161290323
   }
  }
 },
 "not_on_a_readable_page": {
  "google_aio": {
   "n": 117,
   "of": 640,
   "share": 0.1828125,
   "not_found": 34,
   "access_failure": 83,
   "in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
    "n": 15,
    "of": 640,
    "share": 0.0234375
   },
   "figures_the_check_could_not_read": 1,
   "every_figure_that_was_not_found": {
    "n": 133,
    "of": 640,
    "share": 0.2078125
   },
   "answers_with_an_unreadable_page": {
    "n": 28,
    "of": 47,
    "share": 0.5957446808510638
   }
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "n": 175,
   "of": 470,
   "share": 0.3723404255319149,
   "not_found": 109,
   "access_failure": 66,
   "in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
    "n": 28,
    "of": 470,
    "share": 0.059574468085106386
   },
   "figures_the_check_could_not_read": 0,
   "every_figure_that_was_not_found": {
    "n": 203,
    "of": 470,
    "share": 0.4319148936170213
   },
   "answers_with_an_unreadable_page": {
    "n": 13,
    "of": 47,
    "share": 0.2765957446808511
   }
  },
  "gemini": {
   "n": 193,
   "of": 661,
   "share": 0.291981845688351,
   "not_found": 137,
   "access_failure": 56,
   "in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
    "n": 10,
    "of": 661,
    "share": 0.015128593040847202
   },
   "figures_the_check_could_not_read": 5,
   "every_figure_that_was_not_found": {
    "n": 208,
    "of": 661,
    "share": 0.3146747352496218
   },
   "answers_with_an_unreadable_page": {
    "n": 13,
    "of": 50,
    "share": 0.26
   }
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "n": 109,
   "of": 755,
   "share": 0.14437086092715232,
   "not_found": 2,
   "access_failure": 107,
   "in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
    "n": 0,
    "of": 755,
    "share": 0.0
   },
   "figures_the_check_could_not_read": 2,
   "every_figure_that_was_not_found": {
    "n": 111,
    "of": 755,
    "share": 0.14701986754966886
   },
   "answers_with_an_unreadable_page": {
    "n": 42,
    "of": 47,
    "share": 0.8936170212765957
   }
  },
  "claude": {
   "n": 103,
   "of": 939,
   "share": 0.10969116080937168,
   "not_found": 32,
   "access_failure": 71,
   "in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
    "n": 13,
    "of": 939,
    "share": 0.013844515441959531
   },
   "figures_the_check_could_not_read": 1,
   "every_figure_that_was_not_found": {
    "n": 117,
    "of": 939,
    "share": 0.12460063897763578
   },
   "answers_with_an_unreadable_page": {
    "n": 23,
    "of": 50,
    "share": 0.46
   }
  }
 },
 "fully_readable": {
  "google_aio": {
   "answers": 18,
   "median": 0.9495192307692308,
   "interval_95": [
    0.8090909090909091,
    1.0
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 268,
    "of": 302,
    "share": 0.8874172185430463
   }
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "answers": 30,
   "median": 0.6125,
   "interval_95": [
    0.45833333333333337,
    0.8666666666666667
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 217,
    "of": 326,
    "share": 0.6656441717791411
   }
  },
  "gemini": {
   "answers": 36,
   "median": 0.75,
   "interval_95": [
    0.6583333333333333,
    0.9090909090909091
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 347,
    "of": 489,
    "share": 0.7096114519427403
   }
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "answers": 5,
   "median": 1.0,
   "interval_95": [
    0.8823529411764706,
    1.0
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 61,
    "of": 63,
    "share": 0.9682539682539683
   }
  },
  "claude": {
   "answers": 25,
   "median": 1.0,
   "interval_95": [
    0.9090909090909091,
    1.0
   ],
   "pooled": {
    "n": 397,
    "of": 430,
    "share": 0.9232558139534883
   }
  }
 },
 "sectors": {
  "google_aio": {
   "ai_tools": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 112,
     "of": 113,
     "share": 0.9911504424778761
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 113,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 112,
     "of": 113,
     "share": 0.9911504424778761
    }
   },
   "business_software": {
    "answers_with_figures": 9,
    "found": {
     "n": 71,
     "of": 90,
     "share": 0.7888888888888889
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 90,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 71,
     "of": 90,
     "share": 0.7888888888888889
    }
   },
   "consumer_electronics": {
    "answers_with_figures": 7,
    "found": {
     "n": 61,
     "of": 89,
     "share": 0.6853932584269663
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [
     "ELC-16"
    ],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 15,
     "of": 89,
     "share": 0.16853932584269662
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 61,
     "of": 74,
     "share": 0.8243243243243243
    }
   },
   "legal_local_services": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 111,
     "of": 135,
     "share": 0.8222222222222222
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 135,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 111,
     "of": 135,
     "share": 0.8222222222222222
    }
   },
   "personal_finance": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 89,
     "of": 122,
     "share": 0.7295081967213115
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 122,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 89,
     "of": 122,
     "share": 0.7295081967213115
    }
   },
   "travel": {
    "answers_with_figures": 7,
    "found": {
     "n": 63,
     "of": 91,
     "share": 0.6923076923076923
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 91,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 63,
     "of": 91,
     "share": 0.6923076923076923
    }
   }
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "ai_tools": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 78,
     "of": 85,
     "share": 0.9176470588235294
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 85,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 78,
     "of": 85,
     "share": 0.9176470588235294
    }
   },
   "business_software": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 40,
     "of": 92,
     "share": 0.43478260869565216
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 92,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 40,
     "of": 92,
     "share": 0.43478260869565216
    }
   },
   "consumer_electronics": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 51,
     "of": 89,
     "share": 0.5730337078651685
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 89,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 51,
     "of": 89,
     "share": 0.5730337078651685
    }
   },
   "legal_local_services": {
    "answers_with_figures": 7,
    "found": {
     "n": 25,
     "of": 65,
     "share": 0.38461538461538464
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [
     "SVC-06",
     "SVC-09",
     "SVC-10"
    ],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 26,
     "of": 65,
     "share": 0.4
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 25,
     "of": 39,
     "share": 0.6410256410256411
    }
   },
   "personal_finance": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 55,
     "of": 84,
     "share": 0.6547619047619048
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 84,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 55,
     "of": 84,
     "share": 0.6547619047619048
    }
   },
   "travel": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 18,
     "of": 55,
     "share": 0.32727272727272727
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [
     "TRV-08"
    ],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 55,
     "share": 0.03636363636363636
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 18,
     "of": 53,
     "share": 0.33962264150943394
    }
   }
  },
  "gemini": {
   "ai_tools": {
    "answers_with_figures": 9,
    "found": {
     "n": 87,
     "of": 88,
     "share": 0.9886363636363636
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 88,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 87,
     "of": 88,
     "share": 0.9886363636363636
    }
   },
   "business_software": {
    "answers_with_figures": 9,
    "found": {
     "n": 118,
     "of": 157,
     "share": 0.7515923566878981
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 157,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 118,
     "of": 157,
     "share": 0.7515923566878981
    }
   },
   "consumer_electronics": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 32,
     "of": 74,
     "share": 0.43243243243243246
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [
     "ELC-13"
    ],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 10,
     "of": 74,
     "share": 0.13513513513513514
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 32,
     "of": 64,
     "share": 0.5
    }
   },
   "legal_local_services": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 106,
     "of": 150,
     "share": 0.7066666666666667
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 150,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 106,
     "of": 150,
     "share": 0.7066666666666667
    }
   },
   "personal_finance": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 65,
     "of": 120,
     "share": 0.5416666666666666
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 120,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 65,
     "of": 120,
     "share": 0.5416666666666666
    }
   },
   "travel": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 45,
     "of": 72,
     "share": 0.625
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 72,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 45,
     "of": 72,
     "share": 0.625
    }
   }
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "ai_tools": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 115,
     "of": 116,
     "share": 0.9913793103448276
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 116,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 115,
     "of": 116,
     "share": 0.9913793103448276
    }
   },
   "business_software": {
    "answers_with_figures": 9,
    "found": {
     "n": 200,
     "of": 250,
     "share": 0.8
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 250,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 200,
     "of": 250,
     "share": 0.8
    }
   },
   "consumer_electronics": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 107,
     "of": 117,
     "share": 0.9145299145299145
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 117,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 107,
     "of": 117,
     "share": 0.9145299145299145
    }
   },
   "legal_local_services": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 90,
     "of": 105,
     "share": 0.8571428571428571
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 105,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 90,
     "of": 105,
     "share": 0.8571428571428571
    }
   },
   "personal_finance": {
    "answers_with_figures": 7,
    "found": {
     "n": 80,
     "of": 98,
     "share": 0.8163265306122449
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 98,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 80,
     "of": 98,
     "share": 0.8163265306122449
    }
   },
   "travel": {
    "answers_with_figures": 7,
    "found": {
     "n": 52,
     "of": 69,
     "share": 0.7536231884057971
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 69,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 52,
     "of": 69,
     "share": 0.7536231884057971
    }
   }
  },
  "claude": {
   "ai_tools": {
    "answers_with_figures": 9,
    "found": {
     "n": 118,
     "of": 119,
     "share": 0.9915966386554622
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 119,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 118,
     "of": 119,
     "share": 0.9915966386554622
    }
   },
   "business_software": {
    "answers_with_figures": 9,
    "found": {
     "n": 229,
     "of": 240,
     "share": 0.9541666666666667
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 240,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 229,
     "of": 240,
     "share": 0.9541666666666667
    }
   },
   "consumer_electronics": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 104,
     "of": 127,
     "share": 0.8188976377952756
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 127,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 104,
     "of": 127,
     "share": 0.8188976377952756
    }
   },
   "legal_local_services": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 168,
     "of": 182,
     "share": 0.9230769230769231
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 182,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 168,
     "of": 182,
     "share": 0.9230769230769231
    }
   },
   "personal_finance": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 126,
     "of": 162,
     "share": 0.7777777777777778
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 162,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 126,
     "of": 162,
     "share": 0.7777777777777778
    }
   },
   "travel": {
    "answers_with_figures": 8,
    "found": {
     "n": 77,
     "of": 109,
     "share": 0.7064220183486238
    },
    "answers_that_cite_no_source": [
     "TRV-08",
     "TRV-16"
    ],
    "figures_in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 13,
     "of": 109,
     "share": 0.11926605504587157
    },
    "found_in_answers_that_cite_a_source": {
     "n": 77,
     "of": 96,
     "share": 0.8020833333333334
    }
   }
  },
  "answers_per_cell": {
   "fewest": 7,
   "most": 9
  }
 },
 "validation": {
  "figures": 40,
  "by_stratum_and_engine": {
   "found": {
    "google_aio": 6,
    "gemini": 11,
    "chatgpt": 3
   },
   "not_found": {
    "chatgpt": 9,
    "google_aio": 1,
    "gemini": 10
   }
  },
  "sampled_figures_the_classifier_called_absent": {
   "read_as_something_else": {
    "n": 4,
    "of": 15,
    "share": 0.26666666666666666
   },
   "readings": {
    "derived": 2,
    "partial": 2
   },
   "disagreements_in_the_not_found_sample": 4
  },
  "readings_with_a_confirmed_quote": {
   "n": 35,
   "of": 40,
   "share": 0.875
  },
  "readings_without_a_quote": {
   "n": 5,
   "readings": {
    "absent": 5
   }
  },
  "found_sample_number_only": {
   "n": 4,
   "of": 20,
   "share": 0.2
  },
  "found_sample_number_only_readings": {
   "supports": 3,
   "coincidental": 1
  },
  "found_sample_readings": {
   "supports": 19,
   "coincidental": 1
  },
  "classifier_labels_all_engines": {
   "absent": 184,
   "partial": 87,
   "rounded": 8,
   "derived": 0,
   "present": 1,
   "unlabelled": 0,
   "absent_quote_unconfirmed": 10,
   "not_found": 280
  }
 },
 "frame": {
  "answers_collected": {
   "n": 149,
   "of": 150,
   "share": 0.9933333333333333
  },
  "answers_with_figures": 144,
  "figures": 1771,
  "found": 1227,
  "repeat_answers_collected": {
   "n": 28,
   "of": 30,
   "share": 0.9333333333333333
  },
  "chatgpt_answers_without_a_source": {
   "n": 6,
   "saved_pages": {
    "BIZ-04": {
     "sources_controls": 0,
     "tagged_outbound_links": 0
    },
    "SVC-06": {
     "sources_controls": 0,
     "tagged_outbound_links": 0
    },
    "SVC-07": {
     "sources_controls": 0,
     "tagged_outbound_links": 0
    },
    "SVC-09": {
     "sources_controls": 0,
     "tagged_outbound_links": 0
    },
    "SVC-10": {
     "sources_controls": 0,
     "tagged_outbound_links": 0
    },
    "TRV-08": {
     "sources_controls": 0,
     "tagged_outbound_links": 0
    }
   },
   "saved_page_of_a_sourced_answer_for_reference": {
    "AIT-03": {
     "sources_controls": 2,
     "tagged_outbound_links": 59
    }
   },
   "without_a_figure": [
    "BIZ-04",
    "SVC-07"
   ],
   "with_figures": [
    "SVC-06",
    "SVC-09",
    "SVC-10",
    "TRV-08"
   ],
   "figures_in_them": 28
  },
  "cited_addresses": 483,
  "readable_addresses": 410,
  "addresses_with_text_in_a_fetch": {
   "n": 429,
   "of": 483,
   "set_aside_by_the_check": 19,
   "every_text_under_500_characters": 19,
   "a_check_page_among_the_texts": 0
  },
  "utc_offsets_of_the_timestamps": [
   "+0300"
  ],
  "main_set_first_and_last_answer": [
   "2026-10-05T16:34:54+0300",
   "2026-10-07T00:08:15+0300"
  ],
  "repeat_set_first_and_last_answer": [
   "2026-10-07T00:25:54+0300",
   "2026-10-07T01:23:51+0300"
  ]
 },
 "perplexity_and_claude": {
  "note": "Perplexity and Claude were added on 6 October 2026, after the preregistration, and their answers went through the same four steps on 7 and 8 October (deviation log, entries 3, 5 and 6). Read from addendum/figures/. The values of Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT and Gemini are unchanged.",
  "engines": [
   "google_aio",
   "chatgpt",
   "gemini",
   "perplexity",
   "claude"
  ],
  "all_answers_with_figures": {
   "google_aio": {
    "answers": 47,
    "median": 0.8214285714285714,
    "interval_95": [
     0.7222222222222222,
     0.9230769230769231
    ]
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "answers": 47,
    "median": 0.5454545454545454,
    "interval_95": [
     0.4,
     0.6923076923076923
    ]
   },
   "gemini": {
    "answers": 50,
    "median": 0.7321428571428572,
    "interval_95": [
     0.6583333333333333,
     0.8333333333333334
    ]
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "answers": 47,
    "median": 0.9365079365079365,
    "interval_95": [
     0.8636363636363636,
     1.0
    ]
   },
   "claude": {
    "answers": 50,
    "median": 0.9302884615384616,
    "interval_95": [
     0.8888888888888888,
     0.9833333333333334
    ]
   }
  },
  "common_questions_five_engines": {
   "questions": 41,
   "google_aio": {
    "answers": 41,
    "median": 0.8214285714285714,
    "interval_95": [
     0.7222222222222222,
     0.9166666666666666
    ]
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "answers": 41,
    "median": 0.5714285714285714,
    "interval_95": [
     0.4166666666666667,
     0.75
    ]
   },
   "gemini": {
    "answers": 41,
    "median": 0.7142857142857143,
    "interval_95": [
     0.6666666666666666,
     0.9090909090909091
    ]
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "answers": 41,
    "median": 0.9166666666666666,
    "interval_95": [
     0.8571428571428571,
     1.0
    ]
   },
   "claude": {
    "answers": 41,
    "median": 0.9090909090909091,
    "interval_95": [
     0.875,
     0.96
    ]
   },
   "intervals": {
    "google_aio and chatgpt": "overlap",
    "google_aio and gemini": "overlap",
    "google_aio and perplexity": "overlap",
    "google_aio and claude": "overlap",
    "chatgpt and gemini": "overlap",
    "chatgpt and perplexity": "do not overlap",
    "chatgpt and claude": "do not overlap",
    "gemini and perplexity": "overlap",
    "gemini and claude": "overlap",
    "perplexity and claude": "overlap"
   },
   "questions_of_the_three_registered_engines": 44,
   "of_them_not_among_the_five_engine_questions": [
    "AIT-12",
    "FIN-09",
    "TRV-08"
   ],
   "added_engines_without_a_figure_there": {
    "perplexity": [
     "AIT-12",
     "FIN-09",
     "TRV-08"
    ],
    "claude": []
   },
   "registered_answers_to_the_questions_that_leave": {
    "AIT-12": {
     "google_aio": {
      "n": 3,
      "of": 3,
      "share": null,
      "cited_pages": 10,
      "readable_pages": 8
     },
     "chatgpt": {
      "n": 1,
      "of": 3,
      "share": null,
      "cited_pages": 1,
      "readable_pages": 1
     },
     "gemini": {
      "n": 1,
      "of": 2,
      "share": null,
      "cited_pages": 2,
      "readable_pages": 2
     }
    },
    "FIN-09": {
     "google_aio": {
      "n": 7,
      "of": 11,
      "share": 0.6363636363636364,
      "cited_pages": 9,
      "readable_pages": 7
     },
     "chatgpt": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 1,
      "share": null,
      "cited_pages": 2,
      "readable_pages": 1
     },
     "gemini": {
      "n": 3,
      "of": 7,
      "share": 0.42857142857142855,
      "cited_pages": 3,
      "readable_pages": 1
     }
    },
    "TRV-08": {
     "google_aio": {
      "n": 2,
      "of": 2,
      "share": null,
      "cited_pages": 5,
      "readable_pages": 4
     },
     "chatgpt": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 2,
      "share": null,
      "cited_pages": 0,
      "readable_pages": 0
     },
     "gemini": {
      "n": 6,
      "of": 8,
      "share": 0.75,
      "cited_pages": 3,
      "readable_pages": 2
     }
    }
   }
  },
  "paired_on_the_five_engine_questions": {
   "perplexity minus chatgpt": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.9166666666666666,
    "second_median": 0.5714285714285714,
    "difference": 0.34523809523809523,
    "interval_95": [
     0.1785714285714286,
     0.5
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 30,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.7317073170731707
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 3,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.07317073170731707
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 8,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.1951219512195122
    }
   },
   "claude minus chatgpt": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.9090909090909091,
    "second_median": 0.5714285714285714,
    "difference": 0.33766233766233766,
    "interval_95": [
     0.1597222222222222,
     0.5064102564102564
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 30,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.7317073170731707
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 5,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.12195121951219512
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 6,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.14634146341463414
    }
   },
   "google_aio minus chatgpt": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.8214285714285714,
    "second_median": 0.5714285714285714,
    "difference": 0.25,
    "interval_95": [
     0.08333333333333337,
     0.4166666666666667
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 27,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.6585365853658537
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 7,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.17073170731707318
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 7,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.17073170731707318
    }
   },
   "perplexity minus google_aio": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.9166666666666666,
    "second_median": 0.8214285714285714,
    "difference": 0.09523809523809523,
    "interval_95": [
     0.0,
     0.1875
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 19,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.4634146341463415
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 13,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.3170731707317073
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 9,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.21951219512195122
    }
   },
   "claude minus google_aio": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.9090909090909091,
    "second_median": 0.8214285714285714,
    "difference": 0.08766233766233766,
    "interval_95": [
     0.0058651026392961825,
     0.18571428571428572
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 22,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.5365853658536586
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 14,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.34146341463414637
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 5,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.12195121951219512
    }
   }
  },
  "paired_every_pair_on_the_five_engine_questions": {
   "google_aio minus chatgpt": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.8214285714285714,
    "second_median": 0.5714285714285714,
    "difference": 0.25,
    "interval_95": [
     0.08333333333333337,
     0.4166666666666667
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 27,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.6585365853658537
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 7,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.17073170731707318
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 7,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.17073170731707318
    }
   },
   "google_aio minus gemini": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.8214285714285714,
    "second_median": 0.7142857142857143,
    "difference": 0.1071428571428571,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.051948051948051965,
     0.1875
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 21,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.5121951219512195
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 12,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.2926829268292683
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 8,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.1951219512195122
    }
   },
   "google_aio minus perplexity": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.8214285714285714,
    "second_median": 0.9166666666666666,
    "difference": -0.09523809523809523,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.1875,
     0.0
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 13,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.3170731707317073
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 19,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.4634146341463415
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 9,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.21951219512195122
    }
   },
   "google_aio minus claude": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.8214285714285714,
    "second_median": 0.9090909090909091,
    "difference": -0.08766233766233766,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.18571428571428572,
     -0.0058651026392961825
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 14,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.34146341463414637
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 22,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.5365853658536586
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 5,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.12195121951219512
    }
   },
   "chatgpt minus gemini": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.5714285714285714,
    "second_median": 0.7142857142857143,
    "difference": -0.1428571428571429,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.36363636363636365,
     0.004807692307692291
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 11,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.2682926829268293
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 23,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.5609756097560976
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 7,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.17073170731707318
    }
   },
   "chatgpt minus perplexity": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.5714285714285714,
    "second_median": 0.9166666666666666,
    "difference": -0.34523809523809523,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.5,
     -0.1785714285714286
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 3,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.07317073170731707
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 30,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.7317073170731707
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 8,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.1951219512195122
    }
   },
   "chatgpt minus claude": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.5714285714285714,
    "second_median": 0.9090909090909091,
    "difference": -0.33766233766233766,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.5064102564102564,
     -0.1597222222222222
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 5,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.12195121951219512
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 30,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.7317073170731707
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 6,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.14634146341463414
    }
   },
   "gemini minus perplexity": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.7142857142857143,
    "second_median": 0.9166666666666666,
    "difference": -0.20238095238095233,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.3125,
     -0.008333333333333304
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 10,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.24390243902439024
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 23,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.5609756097560976
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 8,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.1951219512195122
    }
   },
   "gemini minus claude": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.7142857142857143,
    "second_median": 0.9090909090909091,
    "difference": -0.19480519480519476,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.26262626262626265,
     -0.02840909090909094
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 11,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.2682926829268293
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 23,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.5609756097560976
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 7,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.17073170731707318
    }
   },
   "perplexity minus claude": {
    "questions": 41,
    "statistic": "difference of the medians",
    "first_median": 0.9166666666666666,
    "second_median": 0.9090909090909091,
    "difference": 0.007575757575757569,
    "interval_95": [
     -0.07386363636363635,
     0.09090909090909094
    ],
    "first_higher": {
     "n": 17,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.4146341463414634
    },
    "first_lower": {
     "n": 15,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.36585365853658536
    },
    "equal": {
     "n": 9,
     "of": 41,
     "share": 0.21951219512195122
    }
   }
  },
  "common_citing_questions_five_engines": {
   "questions": 35,
   "google_aio": {
    "answers": 35,
    "median": 0.8181818181818182,
    "interval_95": [
     0.7142857142857143,
     0.9230769230769231
    ]
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "answers": 35,
    "median": 0.5714285714285714,
    "interval_95": [
     0.43478260869565216,
     0.8181818181818182
    ]
   },
   "gemini": {
    "answers": 35,
    "median": 0.7777777777777778,
    "interval_95": [
     0.6818181818181818,
     0.9230769230769231
    ]
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "answers": 35,
    "median": 0.8823529411764706,
    "interval_95": [
     0.75,
     0.9523809523809523
    ]
   },
   "claude": {
    "answers": 35,
    "median": 0.9090909090909091,
    "interval_95": [
     0.875,
     0.9666666666666667
    ]
   },
   "intervals": {
    "google_aio and chatgpt": "overlap",
    "google_aio and gemini": "overlap",
    "google_aio and perplexity": "overlap",
    "google_aio and claude": "overlap",
    "chatgpt and gemini": "overlap",
    "chatgpt and perplexity": "overlap",
    "chatgpt and claude": "do not overlap",
    "gemini and perplexity": "overlap",
    "gemini and claude": "overlap",
    "perplexity and claude": "overlap"
   }
  },
  "outcomes": {
   "perplexity": {
    "figures": 755,
    "answers_with_figures": 47,
    "found": {
     "n": 644,
     "of": 755,
     "share": 0.8529801324503311
    },
    "found_attached": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 755,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_elsewhere": {
     "n": 644,
     "of": 755,
     "share": 0.8529801324503311
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 755,
     "share": 0.0026490066225165563
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 109,
     "of": 755,
     "share": 0.14437086092715232
    }
   },
   "claude": {
    "figures": 939,
    "answers_with_figures": 50,
    "found": {
     "n": 822,
     "of": 939,
     "share": 0.8753993610223643
    },
    "found_attached": {
     "n": 574,
     "of": 939,
     "share": 0.6112886048988285
    },
    "found_elsewhere": {
     "n": 248,
     "of": 939,
     "share": 0.2641107561235357
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 32,
     "of": 939,
     "share": 0.03407880724174654
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 85,
     "of": 939,
     "share": 0.09052183173588925
    }
   }
  },
  "attached": {
   "perplexity": {
    "available": false
   },
   "claude": {
    "available": true,
    "no_source_attached_to_the_sentence": {
     "n": 233,
     "of": 939,
     "share": 0.24813631522896698
    },
    "the_same_in_answers_that_cite_a_page": {
     "n": 220,
     "of": 926,
     "share": 0.23758099352051837
    },
    "found_on_the_attached_source_where_one_is_attached": {
     "n": 574,
     "of": 706,
     "share": 0.8130311614730878
    },
    "found_elsewhere_with_no_source_attached": {
     "n": 188,
     "of": 248,
     "share": 0.7580645161290323
    }
   }
  },
  "not_on_a_readable_page": {
   "perplexity": {
    "n": 109,
    "of": 755,
    "share": 0.14437086092715232,
    "not_found": 2,
    "access_failure": 107,
    "in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 755,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "figures_the_check_could_not_read": 2,
    "every_figure_that_was_not_found": {
     "n": 111,
     "of": 755,
     "share": 0.14701986754966886
    },
    "answers_with_an_unreadable_page": {
     "n": 42,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.8936170212765957
    }
   },
   "claude": {
    "n": 103,
    "of": 939,
    "share": 0.10969116080937168,
    "not_found": 32,
    "access_failure": 71,
    "in_answers_that_cite_no_source": {
     "n": 13,
     "of": 939,
     "share": 0.013844515441959531
    },
    "figures_the_check_could_not_read": 1,
    "every_figure_that_was_not_found": {
     "n": 117,
     "of": 939,
     "share": 0.12460063897763578
    },
    "answers_with_an_unreadable_page": {
     "n": 23,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.46
    }
   }
  },
  "fully_readable": {
   "perplexity": {
    "answers": 5,
    "median": 1.0,
    "interval_95": [
     0.8823529411764706,
     1.0
    ],
    "pooled": {
     "n": 61,
     "of": 63,
     "share": 0.9682539682539683
    }
   },
   "claude": {
    "answers": 25,
    "median": 1.0,
    "interval_95": [
     0.9090909090909091,
     1.0
    ],
    "pooled": {
     "n": 397,
     "of": 430,
     "share": 0.9232558139534883
    }
   }
  },
  "units": {
   "perplexity": {
    "with_unit": {
     "n": 467,
     "of": 576,
     "share": 0.8107638888888888
    },
    "number_only": {
     "n": 177,
     "of": 177,
     "share": 1.0
    },
    "found_figures_matched_on_the_number_alone": {
     "n": 177,
     "of": 644,
     "share": 0.2748447204968944
    }
   },
   "claude": {
    "with_unit": {
     "n": 678,
     "of": 775,
     "share": 0.8748387096774194
    },
    "number_only": {
     "n": 144,
     "of": 163,
     "share": 0.8834355828220859
    },
    "found_figures_matched_on_the_number_alone": {
     "n": 144,
     "of": 822,
     "share": 0.17518248175182483
    }
   }
  },
  "without_a_source": {
   "perplexity": {
    "answers": [],
    "figures": 0
   },
   "claude": {
    "answers": [
     "TRV-08",
     "TRV-16"
    ],
    "figures": 13
   }
  },
  "pages_per_answer": {
   "google_aio": {
    "answers": 47,
    "median_cited_pages": 7,
    "median_readable_pages": 6,
    "answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
     "n": 1,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.02127659574468085
    },
    "found_in_answers_with_two_or_more_readable_pages": {
     "answers": 46,
     "n": 507,
     "of": 625,
     "share": 0.8112
    },
    "figure_page_pairs": {
     "n": 1617,
     "of": 4235,
     "share": 0.38181818181818183
    },
    "cut_to_k_pages": {
     "2": {
      "pooled_share": 0.5721901592076224,
      "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
       "n": 1,
       "of": 47,
       "share": 0.02127659574468085
      }
     },
     "3": {
      "pooled_share": 0.6531159679781002,
      "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
       "n": 6,
       "of": 47,
       "share": 0.1276595744680851
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "chatgpt": {
    "answers": 47,
    "median_cited_pages": 2,
    "median_readable_pages": 1,
    "answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
     "n": 25,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.5319148936170213
    },
    "found_in_answers_with_two_or_more_readable_pages": {
     "answers": 22,
     "n": 186,
     "of": 262,
     "share": 0.7099236641221374
    },
    "figure_page_pairs": {
     "n": 367,
     "of": 832,
     "share": 0.4411057692307692
    },
    "cut_to_k_pages": {
     "2": {
      "pooled_share": 0.5424113475177302,
      "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
       "n": 25,
       "of": 47,
       "share": 0.5319148936170213
      }
     },
     "3": {
      "pooled_share": 0.5617021276595745,
      "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
       "n": 39,
       "of": 47,
       "share": 0.8297872340425532
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "gemini": {
    "answers": 50,
    "median_cited_pages": 3.0,
    "median_readable_pages": 2.0,
    "answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
     "n": 12,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.24
    },
    "found_in_answers_with_two_or_more_readable_pages": {
     "answers": 38,
     "n": 410,
     "of": 541,
     "share": 0.7578558225508318
    },
    "figure_page_pairs": {
     "n": 876,
     "of": 1671,
     "share": 0.5242369838420108
    },
    "cut_to_k_pages": {
     "2": {
      "pooled_share": 0.6258698940998487,
      "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
       "n": 12,
       "of": 50,
       "share": 0.24
      }
     },
     "3": {
      "pooled_share": 0.6726928895612706,
      "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
       "n": 29,
       "of": 50,
       "share": 0.58
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "answers": 47,
    "median_cited_pages": 10,
    "median_readable_pages": 9,
    "answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 47,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "found_in_answers_with_two_or_more_readable_pages": {
     "answers": 47,
     "n": 644,
     "of": 755,
     "share": 0.8529801324503311
    },
    "figure_page_pairs": {
     "n": 3436,
     "of": 7613,
     "share": 0.45133324576382505
    },
    "cut_to_k_pages": {
     "2": {
      "pooled_share": 0.594516887086424,
      "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
       "n": 0,
       "of": 47,
       "share": 0.0
      }
     },
     "3": {
      "pooled_share": 0.6760710490301781,
      "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
       "n": 1,
       "of": 47,
       "share": 0.02127659574468085
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "claude": {
    "answers": 50,
    "median_cited_pages": 6.0,
    "median_readable_pages": 5.0,
    "answers_with_at_most_one_readable_page": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.04
    },
    "found_in_answers_with_two_or_more_readable_pages": {
     "answers": 48,
     "n": 822,
     "of": 926,
     "share": 0.8876889848812095
    },
    "figure_page_pairs": {
     "n": 2280,
     "of": 4576,
     "share": 0.4982517482517482
    },
    "cut_to_k_pages": {
     "2": {
      "pooled_share": 0.6688777321365171,
      "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
       "n": 2,
       "of": 50,
       "share": 0.04
      }
     },
     "3": {
      "pooled_share": 0.7617450174958159,
      "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
       "n": 4,
       "of": 50,
       "share": 0.08
      }
     }
    }
   }
  },
  "perplexity_without_SVC-07": {
   "answers": 46,
   "median": 0.9297924297924298,
   "interval_95": [
    0.8636363636363636,
    1.0
   ],
   "found": {
    "n": 641,
    "of": 752,
    "share": 0.8523936170212766
   },
   "the_answer_has_figures": true,
   "figures_of_the_answer": {
    "n": 3,
    "of": 3,
    "share": null
   },
   "among_the_five_engine_questions": false,
   "registered_engines_without_a_figure_for_it": [
    "chatgpt"
   ]
  },
  "pages_and_dates": {
   "time_zone": "UTC+3",
   "figure_chain_first_and_last_log_line": [
    "2026-10-07T23:41",
    "2026-10-08T05:07"
   ],
   "answers_collected": {
    "perplexity": [
     "2026-10-06T17:07+03:00",
     "2026-10-06T22:08+03:00"
    ],
    "claude": [
     "2026-10-06T22:39+03:00",
     "2026-10-06T22:44+03:00"
    ]
   },
   "distinct_addresses_cited": 722,
   "readable_addresses": {
    "n": 601,
    "of": 722,
    "share": 0.832409972299169
   },
   "reused_from_the_registered_sets": {
    "n": 147,
    "of": 722,
    "share": 0.203601108033241,
    "readable": 144,
    "fetched_from": "2026-10-05T17:28+03:00",
    "fetched_until": "2026-10-07T14:10+03:00",
    "hours_from_an_answer_to_the_fetch": [
     -29.269998055555558,
     20.845253333333332
    ],
    "fetched_before_an_added_answer_that_cites_the_address": {
     "n": 108,
     "of": 147,
     "share": 0.7346938775510204
    },
    "fetched_before_every_added_answer_that_cites_the_address": {
     "n": 107,
     "of": 147,
     "share": 0.7278911564625851
    }
   },
   "fetched_for_this_analysis": {
    "n": 575,
    "of": 722,
    "share": 0.796398891966759,
    "readable": 457,
    "fetched_from": "2026-10-07T23:57+03:00",
    "fetched_until": "2026-10-08T04:56+03:00",
    "hours_from_an_answer_to_the_fetch": [
     25.342185555555556,
     34.09235638888889
    ]
   },
   "registered_main_set": {
    "addresses": 483,
    "hours_from_the_first_answer_that_cites_an_address_to_its_fetch": [
     0.12886305555555555,
     2.037970833333333
    ],
    "citations_of_an_address_fetched_before_the_answer": {
     "n": 64,
     "of": 576,
     "share": 0.1111111111111111
    }
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "source_entries": 608,
    "distinct_addresses": 553,
    "median_source_entries_per_answer": 10.0,
    "records_with_the_preview_notice": {
     "n": 5,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.1
    },
    "records_whose_note_says_the_notice_could_not_be_observed": 10,
    "source_entries_whose_query_string_was_not_kept": {
     "n": 22,
     "of": 608,
     "share": 0.03618421052631579
    },
    "addresses_without_their_query_string": 19,
    "answers_with_such_an_address": 14,
    "found_figures_on_such_a_page": {
     "n": 70,
     "of": 644,
     "share": 0.10869565217391304
    },
    "found_figures_only_on_such_pages": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 644,
     "share": 0.003105590062111801
    },
    "site_name_chip_lines": 394,
    "citation_chip_lines_left_out_of_the_text": 534,
    "of_them_counter_lines": 140
   },
   "claude": {
    "source_entries": 272,
    "distinct_addresses": 236,
    "answers_with_citations": {
     "n": 48,
     "of": 50,
     "share": 0.96
    },
    "cited_blocks": 524,
    "citation_entries": 537
   },
   "figures_of_the_added_engines_in_the_validation_sample": 0,
   "five_engines": {
    "distinct_addresses_cited": 1045,
    "addresses_cited_in_the_main_set_and_by_perplexity_or_claude": 160,
    "of_them_not_readable_in_the_main_set_and_fetched_again": 20,
    "of_those_readable_in_the_later_fetch": 7,
    "readable_in_at_least_one_fetch": {
     "n": 874,
     "of": 1045,
     "share": 0.8363636363636363
    }
   }
  },
  "placebo": {
   "registered_pool": {
    "pool": "The pool of the registered placebo: the readable pages of the registered main set, without the pages that Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT or Gemini cite for a question of the answer's sector.",
    "pool_pages_by_sector": {
     "ai_tools": 343,
     "business_software": 327,
     "consumer_electronics": 352,
     "legal_local_services": 343,
     "personal_finance": 344,
     "travel": 341
    },
    "pool_pages_an_added_engine_cites_in_the_sector": {
     "ai_tools": 0,
     "business_software": 0,
     "consumer_electronics": 0,
     "legal_local_services": 0,
     "personal_finance": 0,
     "travel": 0
    },
    "google_aio": {
     "all": {
      "figures": 640,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2805732113954027,
      "actual": {
       "n": 507,
       "of": 640,
       "share": 0.7921875
      }
     },
     "number_only": {
      "figures": 166,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.5524339784139652,
      "actual": {
       "n": 152,
       "of": 166,
       "share": 0.9156626506024096
      }
     },
     "with_unit": {
      "figures": 473,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.18575647965399483,
      "actual": {
       "n": 355,
       "of": 473,
       "share": 0.7505285412262156
      }
     },
     "by_sector": {
      "ai_tools": {
       "figures": 113,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4184777436179273,
       "actual": {
        "n": 112,
        "of": 113,
        "share": 0.9911504424778761
       }
      },
      "business_software": {
       "figures": 90,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.23837912027362307,
       "actual": {
        "n": 71,
        "of": 90,
        "share": 0.7888888888888889
       }
      },
      "consumer_electronics": {
       "figures": 89,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.22394571825232845,
       "actual": {
        "n": 61,
        "of": 89,
        "share": 0.6853932584269663
       }
      },
      "legal_local_services": {
       "figures": 135,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2107220939173492,
       "actual": {
        "n": 111,
        "of": 135,
        "share": 0.8222222222222222
       }
      },
      "personal_finance": {
       "figures": 122,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.16998177907849937,
       "actual": {
        "n": 89,
        "of": 122,
        "share": 0.7295081967213115
       }
      },
      "travel": {
       "figures": 91,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4583331954805446,
       "actual": {
        "n": 63,
        "of": 91,
        "share": 0.6923076923076923
       }
      }
     }
    },
    "chatgpt": {
     "all": {
      "figures": 470,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.18017133902375326,
      "actual": {
       "n": 267,
       "of": 470,
       "share": 0.5680851063829787
      }
     },
     "number_only": {
      "figures": 105,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4967143735809169,
      "actual": {
       "n": 81,
       "of": 105,
       "share": 0.7714285714285715
      }
     },
     "with_unit": {
      "figures": 365,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.08911101401415847,
      "actual": {
       "n": 186,
       "of": 365,
       "share": 0.5095890410958904
      }
     },
     "by_sector": {
      "ai_tools": {
       "figures": 85,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2570249375814385,
       "actual": {
        "n": 78,
        "of": 85,
        "share": 0.9176470588235294
       }
      },
      "business_software": {
       "figures": 92,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.16270608953783935,
       "actual": {
        "n": 40,
        "of": 92,
        "share": 0.43478260869565216
       }
      },
      "consumer_electronics": {
       "figures": 89,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.19904881687185058,
       "actual": {
        "n": 51,
        "of": 89,
        "share": 0.5730337078651685
       }
      },
      "legal_local_services": {
       "figures": 65,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.10442001472804287,
       "actual": {
        "n": 25,
        "of": 65,
        "share": 0.38461538461538464
       }
      },
      "personal_finance": {
       "figures": 84,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.14448991748757392,
       "actual": {
        "n": 55,
        "of": 84,
        "share": 0.6547619047619048
       }
      },
      "travel": {
       "figures": 55,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.20408455784339868,
       "actual": {
        "n": 18,
        "of": 55,
        "share": 0.32727272727272727
       }
      }
     }
    },
    "gemini": {
     "all": {
      "figures": 661,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.19924581354174808,
      "actual": {
       "n": 453,
       "of": 661,
       "share": 0.6853252647503782
      }
     },
     "number_only": {
      "figures": 181,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.47400621360017314,
      "actual": {
       "n": 141,
       "of": 181,
       "share": 0.7790055248618785
      }
     },
     "with_unit": {
      "figures": 475,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.09664496439887184,
      "actual": {
       "n": 312,
       "of": 475,
       "share": 0.6568421052631579
      }
     },
     "by_sector": {
      "ai_tools": {
       "figures": 88,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.29599275007123294,
       "actual": {
        "n": 87,
        "of": 88,
        "share": 0.9886363636363636
       }
      },
      "business_software": {
       "figures": 157,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.17254616467567502,
       "actual": {
        "n": 118,
        "of": 157,
        "share": 0.7515923566878981
       }
      },
      "consumer_electronics": {
       "figures": 74,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.12052242972371914,
       "actual": {
        "n": 32,
        "of": 74,
        "share": 0.43243243243243246
       }
      },
      "legal_local_services": {
       "figures": 150,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2069968738141237,
       "actual": {
        "n": 106,
        "of": 150,
        "share": 0.7066666666666667
       }
      },
      "personal_finance": {
       "figures": 120,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.11173986709628934,
       "actual": {
        "n": 65,
        "of": 120,
        "share": 0.5416666666666666
       }
      },
      "travel": {
       "figures": 72,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.34982497177107685,
       "actual": {
        "n": 45,
        "of": 72,
        "share": 0.625
       }
      }
     }
    },
    "perplexity": {
     "all": {
      "figures": 755,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4035048439834926,
      "actual": {
       "n": 644,
       "of": 755,
       "share": 0.8529801324503311
      }
     },
     "number_only": {
      "figures": 177,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.6586796305075543,
      "actual": {
       "n": 177,
       "of": 177,
       "share": 1.0
      }
     },
     "with_unit": {
      "figures": 576,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.32649281702725735,
      "actual": {
       "n": 467,
       "of": 576,
       "share": 0.8107638888888888
      }
     },
     "by_sector": {
      "ai_tools": {
       "figures": 116,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.6118035200748074,
       "actual": {
        "n": 115,
        "of": 116,
        "share": 0.9913793103448276
       }
      },
      "business_software": {
       "figures": 250,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.44656682182172436,
       "actual": {
        "n": 200,
        "of": 250,
        "share": 0.8
       }
      },
      "consumer_electronics": {
       "figures": 117,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.395562309395587,
       "actual": {
        "n": 107,
        "of": 117,
        "share": 0.9145299145299145
       }
      },
      "legal_local_services": {
       "figures": 105,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.1919089728524547,
       "actual": {
        "n": 90,
        "of": 105,
        "share": 0.8571428571428571
       }
      },
      "personal_finance": {
       "figures": 98,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.26987832366964715,
       "actual": {
        "n": 80,
        "of": 98,
        "share": 0.8163265306122449
       }
      },
      "travel": {
       "figures": 69,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4225497877537941,
       "actual": {
        "n": 52,
        "of": 69,
        "share": 0.7536231884057971
       }
      }
     }
    },
    "claude": {
     "all": {
      "figures": 939,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2353422371950998,
      "actual": {
       "n": 822,
       "of": 939,
       "share": 0.8753993610223643
      }
     },
     "number_only": {
      "figures": 163,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.5380903046943922,
      "actual": {
       "n": 144,
       "of": 163,
       "share": 0.8834355828220859
      }
     },
     "with_unit": {
      "figures": 775,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.17197114975614547,
      "actual": {
       "n": 678,
       "of": 775,
       "share": 0.8748387096774194
      }
     },
     "by_sector": {
      "ai_tools": {
       "figures": 119,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4484102085334683,
       "actual": {
        "n": 118,
        "of": 119,
        "share": 0.9915966386554622
       }
      },
      "business_software": {
       "figures": 240,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2675840256178443,
       "actual": {
        "n": 229,
        "of": 240,
        "share": 0.9541666666666667
       }
      },
      "consumer_electronics": {
       "figures": 127,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.26618926653038266,
       "actual": {
        "n": 104,
        "of": 127,
        "share": 0.8188976377952756
       }
      },
      "legal_local_services": {
       "figures": 182,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.1568375770183339,
       "actual": {
        "n": 168,
        "of": 182,
        "share": 0.9230769230769231
       }
      },
      "personal_finance": {
       "figures": 162,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.09681438951139884,
       "actual": {
        "n": 126,
        "of": 162,
        "share": 0.7777777777777778
       }
      },
      "travel": {
       "figures": 109,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.23276121830175636,
       "actual": {
        "n": 77,
        "of": 109,
        "share": 0.7064220183486238
       }
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "added_pool": {
    "pool": "A second pool: the readable pages cited by Perplexity or Claude, without the pages either of them cites for a question of the answer's sector.",
    "pool_pages_by_sector": {
     "ai_tools": 476,
     "business_software": 494,
     "consumer_electronics": 483,
     "legal_local_services": 513,
     "personal_finance": 528,
     "travel": 511
    },
    "pool_pages_an_added_engine_cites_in_the_sector": {
     "ai_tools": 0,
     "business_software": 0,
     "consumer_electronics": 0,
     "legal_local_services": 0,
     "personal_finance": 0,
     "travel": 0
    },
    "google_aio": {
     "all": {
      "figures": 640,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.29706402694063294,
      "actual": {
       "n": 507,
       "of": 640,
       "share": 0.7921875
      }
     },
     "number_only": {
      "figures": 166,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.5650046478246,
      "actual": {
       "n": 152,
       "of": 166,
       "share": 0.9156626506024096
      }
     },
     "with_unit": {
      "figures": 473,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2036579401757324,
      "actual": {
       "n": 355,
       "of": 473,
       "share": 0.7505285412262156
      }
     },
     "by_sector": {
      "ai_tools": {
       "figures": 113,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.45529256998315315,
       "actual": {
        "n": 112,
        "of": 113,
        "share": 0.9911504424778761
       }
      },
      "business_software": {
       "figures": 90,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.27028764488627965,
       "actual": {
        "n": 71,
        "of": 90,
        "share": 0.7888888888888889
       }
      },
      "consumer_electronics": {
       "figures": 89,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.22257024873838294,
       "actual": {
        "n": 61,
        "of": 89,
        "share": 0.6853932584269663
       }
      },
      "legal_local_services": {
       "figures": 135,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.22332120075754114,
       "actual": {
        "n": 111,
        "of": 135,
        "share": 0.8222222222222222
       }
      },
      "personal_finance": {
       "figures": 122,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.16906545780987442,
       "actual": {
        "n": 89,
        "of": 122,
        "share": 0.7295081967213115
       }
      },
      "travel": {
       "figures": 91,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4809222934214808,
       "actual": {
        "n": 63,
        "of": 91,
        "share": 0.6923076923076923
       }
      }
     }
    },
    "chatgpt": {
     "all": {
      "figures": 470,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.19004673194713656,
      "actual": {
       "n": 267,
       "of": 470,
       "share": 0.5680851063829787
      }
     },
     "number_only": {
      "figures": 105,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.5094941226704394,
      "actual": {
       "n": 81,
       "of": 105,
       "share": 0.7714285714285715
      }
     },
     "with_unit": {
      "figures": 365,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.09815090721851533,
      "actual": {
       "n": 186,
       "of": 365,
       "share": 0.5095890410958904
      }
     },
     "by_sector": {
      "ai_tools": {
       "figures": 85,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.28229316886452027,
       "actual": {
        "n": 78,
        "of": 85,
        "share": 0.9176470588235294
       }
      },
      "business_software": {
       "figures": 92,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.18107674729987946,
       "actual": {
        "n": 40,
        "of": 92,
        "share": 0.43478260869565216
       }
      },
      "consumer_electronics": {
       "figures": 89,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.19893173152370397,
       "actual": {
        "n": 51,
        "of": 89,
        "share": 0.5730337078651685
       }
      },
      "legal_local_services": {
       "figures": 65,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.10898797226865901,
       "actual": {
        "n": 25,
        "of": 65,
        "share": 0.38461538461538464
       }
      },
      "personal_finance": {
       "figures": 84,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.1427703917732624,
       "actual": {
        "n": 55,
        "of": 84,
        "share": 0.6547619047619048
       }
      },
      "travel": {
       "figures": 55,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.21611143087371928,
       "actual": {
        "n": 18,
        "of": 55,
        "share": 0.32727272727272727
       }
      }
     }
    },
    "gemini": {
     "all": {
      "figures": 661,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.21278140578711816,
      "actual": {
       "n": 453,
       "of": 661,
       "share": 0.6853252647503782
      }
     },
     "number_only": {
      "figures": 181,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.49193468303909266,
      "actual": {
       "n": 141,
       "of": 181,
       "share": 0.7790055248618785
      }
     },
     "with_unit": {
      "figures": 475,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.10864911914780916,
      "actual": {
       "n": 312,
       "of": 475,
       "share": 0.6568421052631579
      }
     },
     "by_sector": {
      "ai_tools": {
       "figures": 88,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.32942833438262964,
       "actual": {
        "n": 87,
        "of": 88,
        "share": 0.9886363636363636
       }
      },
      "business_software": {
       "figures": 157,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.19568188969195568,
       "actual": {
        "n": 118,
        "of": 157,
        "share": 0.7515923566878981
       }
      },
      "consumer_electronics": {
       "figures": 74,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.11931702822179485,
       "actual": {
        "n": 32,
        "of": 74,
        "share": 0.43243243243243246
       }
      },
      "legal_local_services": {
       "figures": 150,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2134871556120166,
       "actual": {
        "n": 106,
        "of": 150,
        "share": 0.7066666666666667
       }
      },
      "personal_finance": {
       "figures": 120,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.1126162046060622,
       "actual": {
        "n": 65,
        "of": 120,
        "share": 0.5416666666666666
       }
      },
      "travel": {
       "figures": 72,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.3690316824310259,
       "actual": {
        "n": 45,
        "of": 72,
        "share": 0.625
       }
      }
     }
    },
    "perplexity": {
     "all": {
      "figures": 755,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.42548589752096627,
      "actual": {
       "n": 644,
       "of": 755,
       "share": 0.8529801324503311
      }
     },
     "number_only": {
      "figures": 177,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.6756927800402606,
      "actual": {
       "n": 177,
       "of": 177,
       "share": 1.0
      }
     },
     "with_unit": {
      "figures": 576,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.3500767891687555,
      "actual": {
       "n": 467,
       "of": 576,
       "share": 0.8107638888888888
      }
     },
     "by_sector": {
      "ai_tools": {
       "figures": 116,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.6490212792095058,
       "actual": {
        "n": 115,
        "of": 116,
        "share": 0.9913793103448276
       }
      },
      "business_software": {
       "figures": 250,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4893557745810807,
       "actual": {
        "n": 200,
        "of": 250,
        "share": 0.8
       }
      },
      "consumer_electronics": {
       "figures": 117,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.39823613645098305,
       "actual": {
        "n": 107,
        "of": 117,
        "share": 0.9145299145299145
       }
      },
      "legal_local_services": {
       "figures": 105,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.1934789628675473,
       "actual": {
        "n": 90,
        "of": 105,
        "share": 0.8571428571428571
       }
      },
      "personal_finance": {
       "figures": 98,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.261121901787349,
       "actual": {
        "n": 80,
        "of": 98,
        "share": 0.8163265306122449
       }
      },
      "travel": {
       "figures": 69,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.450979350054185,
       "actual": {
        "n": 52,
        "of": 69,
        "share": 0.7536231884057971
       }
      }
     }
    },
    "claude": {
     "all": {
      "figures": 939,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2531122182756358,
      "actual": {
       "n": 822,
       "of": 939,
       "share": 0.8753993610223643
      }
     },
     "number_only": {
      "figures": 163,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.5541462830734925,
      "actual": {
       "n": 144,
       "of": 163,
       "share": 0.8834355828220859
      }
     },
     "with_unit": {
      "figures": 775,
      "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.190124553315926,
      "actual": {
       "n": 678,
       "of": 775,
       "share": 0.8748387096774194
      }
     },
     "by_sector": {
      "ai_tools": {
       "figures": 119,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.4918407361732009,
       "actual": {
        "n": 118,
        "of": 119,
        "share": 0.9915966386554622
       }
      },
      "business_software": {
       "figures": 240,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.30007485919213744,
       "actual": {
        "n": 229,
        "of": 240,
        "share": 0.9541666666666667
       }
      },
      "consumer_electronics": {
       "figures": 127,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.2674873123400416,
       "actual": {
        "n": 104,
        "of": 127,
        "share": 0.8188976377952756
       }
      },
      "legal_local_services": {
       "figures": 182,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.16423623201417087,
       "actual": {
        "n": 168,
        "of": 182,
        "share": 0.9230769230769231
       }
      },
      "personal_finance": {
       "figures": 162,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.09547113322712093,
       "actual": {
        "n": 126,
        "of": 162,
        "share": 0.7777777777777778
       }
      },
      "travel": {
       "figures": 109,
       "placebo_share_exact_expectation": 0.25501974929853366,
       "actual": {
        "n": 77,
        "of": 109,
        "share": 0.7064220183486238
       }
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "added_figures_compared_with_the_check_outputs": 1694
  },
  "robustness": {
   "note": "Each view is a median per answer with the registered interval, and the paired difference of the medians against ChatGPT on the same questions. The last view is the mean of the per-question differences. The intervals of two engines are apart when they do not overlap.",
   "all_figures": {
    "questions": 41,
    "google_aio": {
     "answers": 41,
     "median": 0.8214285714285714,
     "interval_95": [
      0.7222222222222222,
      0.9166666666666666
     ]
    },
    "chatgpt": {
     "answers": 41,
     "median": 0.5714285714285714,
     "interval_95": [
      0.4166666666666667,
      0.75
     ]
    },
    "gemini": {
     "answers": 41,
     "median": 0.7142857142857143,
     "interval_95": [
      0.6666666666666666,
      0.9090909090909091
     ]
    },
    "perplexity": {
     "answers": 41,
     "median": 0.9166666666666666,
     "interval_95": [
      0.8571428571428571,
      1.0
     ]
    },
    "claude": {
     "answers": 41,
     "median": 0.9090909090909091,
     "interval_95": [
      0.875,
      0.96
     ]
    },
    "intervals": {
     "google_aio and chatgpt": "overlap",
     "google_aio and gemini": "overlap",
     "google_aio and perplexity": "overlap",
     "google_aio and claude": "overlap",
     "chatgpt and gemini": "overlap",
     "chatgpt and perplexity": "do not overlap",
     "chatgpt and claude": "do not overlap",
     "gemini and perplexity": "overlap",
     "gemini and claude": "overlap",
     "perplexity and claude": "overlap"
    },
    "intervals_against_chatgpt": {
     "google_aio": "overlap",
     "gemini": "overlap",
     "perplexity": "do not overlap",
     "claude": "do not overlap"
    },
    "paired_against_chatgpt": {
     "google_aio": {
      "questions": 41,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.8214285714285714,
      "second_median": 0.5714285714285714,
      "difference": 0.25,
      "interval_95": [
       0.08333333333333337,
       0.4166666666666667
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 27,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.6585365853658537
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 7,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.17073170731707318
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 7,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.17073170731707318
      }
     },
     "gemini": {
      "questions": 41,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.7142857142857143,
      "second_median": 0.5714285714285714,
      "difference": 0.1428571428571429,
      "interval_95": [
       -0.004807692307692291,
       0.36363636363636365
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 23,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.5609756097560976
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 11,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.2682926829268293
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 7,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.17073170731707318
      }
     },
     "perplexity": {
      "questions": 41,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.9166666666666666,
      "second_median": 0.5714285714285714,
      "difference": 0.34523809523809523,
      "interval_95": [
       0.1785714285714286,
       0.5
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 30,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.7317073170731707
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 3,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.07317073170731707
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 8,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.1951219512195122
      }
     },
     "claude": {
      "questions": 41,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.9090909090909091,
      "second_median": 0.5714285714285714,
      "difference": 0.33766233766233766,
      "interval_95": [
       0.1597222222222222,
       0.5064102564102564
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 30,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.7317073170731707
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 5,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.12195121951219512
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 6,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.14634146341463414
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "figures_with_a_unit": {
    "questions": 39,
    "google_aio": {
     "answers": 39,
     "median": 0.8,
     "interval_95": [
      0.6666666666666666,
      0.9090909090909091
     ]
    },
    "chatgpt": {
     "answers": 39,
     "median": 0.5,
     "interval_95": [
      0.2727272727272727,
      0.6666666666666666
     ]
    },
    "gemini": {
     "answers": 39,
     "median": 0.7,
     "interval_95": [
      0.4666666666666667,
      0.9
     ]
    },
    "perplexity": {
     "answers": 39,
     "median": 0.9,
     "interval_95": [
      0.7777777777777778,
      1.0
     ]
    },
    "claude": {
     "answers": 39,
     "median": 0.9166666666666666,
     "interval_95": [
      0.8461538461538461,
      1.0
     ]
    },
    "intervals": {
     "google_aio and chatgpt": "meet at one value",
     "google_aio and gemini": "overlap",
     "google_aio and perplexity": "overlap",
     "google_aio and claude": "overlap",
     "chatgpt and gemini": "overlap",
     "chatgpt and perplexity": "do not overlap",
     "chatgpt and claude": "do not overlap",
     "gemini and perplexity": "overlap",
     "gemini and claude": "overlap",
     "perplexity and claude": "overlap"
    },
    "intervals_against_chatgpt": {
     "google_aio": "meet at one value",
     "gemini": "overlap",
     "perplexity": "do not overlap",
     "claude": "do not overlap"
    },
    "paired_against_chatgpt": {
     "google_aio": {
      "questions": 39,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.8,
      "second_median": 0.5,
      "difference": 0.30000000000000004,
      "interval_95": [
       0.13636363636363635,
       0.475
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 24,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.6153846153846154
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 7,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.1794871794871795
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 8,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.20512820512820512
      }
     },
     "gemini": {
      "questions": 39,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.7,
      "second_median": 0.5,
      "difference": 0.19999999999999996,
      "interval_95": [
       -0.00952380952380949,
       0.4329004329004329
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 20,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.5128205128205128
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 10,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.2564102564102564
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 9,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.23076923076923078
      }
     },
     "perplexity": {
      "questions": 39,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.9,
      "second_median": 0.5,
      "difference": 0.4,
      "interval_95": [
       0.25108225108225113,
       0.6153846153846154
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 28,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.717948717948718
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 5,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.1282051282051282
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 6,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.15384615384615385
      }
     },
     "claude": {
      "questions": 39,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.9166666666666666,
      "second_median": 0.5,
      "difference": 0.41666666666666663,
      "interval_95": [
       0.2647058823529411,
       0.6272727272727273
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 30,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.7692307692307693
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 3,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.07692307692307693
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 6,
       "of": 39,
       "share": 0.15384615384615385
      }
     }
    },
    "ids": [
     "AIT-03",
     "AIT-04",
     "AIT-05",
     "AIT-06",
     "AIT-10",
     "AIT-16",
     "BIZ-01",
     "BIZ-02",
     "BIZ-05",
     "BIZ-06",
     "BIZ-07",
     "BIZ-08",
     "BIZ-13",
     "ELC-03",
     "ELC-09",
     "ELC-10",
     "ELC-12",
     "ELC-13",
     "ELC-14",
     "ELC-16",
     "FIN-01",
     "FIN-02",
     "FIN-05",
     "FIN-06",
     "FIN-14",
     "FIN-15",
     "FIN-17",
     "SVC-01",
     "SVC-06",
     "SVC-08",
     "SVC-09",
     "SVC-10",
     "SVC-15",
     "SVC-17",
     "TRV-06",
     "TRV-09",
     "TRV-11",
     "TRV-14",
     "TRV-15"
    ]
   },
   "cut_to_two_readable_pages": {
    "questions": 41,
    "google_aio": {
     "answers": 41,
     "median": 0.5388257575757576,
     "interval_95": [
      0.4592592592592593,
      0.6923076923076923
     ]
    },
    "chatgpt": {
     "answers": 41,
     "median": 0.5238095238095238,
     "interval_95": [
      0.4166666666666667,
      0.6666666666666666
     ]
    },
    "gemini": {
     "answers": 41,
     "median": 0.6666666666666665,
     "interval_95": [
      0.5454545454545454,
      0.7142857142857143
     ]
    },
    "perplexity": {
     "answers": 41,
     "median": 0.6006944444444443,
     "interval_95": [
      0.52,
      0.6462585034013605
     ]
    },
    "claude": {
     "answers": 41,
     "median": 0.6909090909090909,
     "interval_95": [
      0.5476190476190477,
      0.761904761904762
     ]
    },
    "intervals": {
     "google_aio and chatgpt": "overlap",
     "google_aio and gemini": "overlap",
     "google_aio and perplexity": "overlap",
     "google_aio and claude": "overlap",
     "chatgpt and gemini": "overlap",
     "chatgpt and perplexity": "overlap",
     "chatgpt and claude": "overlap",
     "gemini and perplexity": "overlap",
     "gemini and claude": "overlap",
     "perplexity and claude": "overlap"
    },
    "intervals_against_chatgpt": {
     "google_aio": "overlap",
     "gemini": "overlap",
     "perplexity": "overlap",
     "claude": "overlap"
    },
    "paired_against_chatgpt": {
     "google_aio": {
      "questions": 41,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.5388257575757576,
      "second_median": 0.5238095238095238,
      "difference": 0.015016233766233733,
      "interval_95": [
       -0.09259259259259256,
       0.16849816849816845
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 15,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.36585365853658536
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 25,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.6097560975609756
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 1,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.024390243902439025
      }
     },
     "gemini": {
      "questions": 41,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.6666666666666665,
      "second_median": 0.5238095238095238,
      "difference": 0.14285714285714268,
      "interval_95": [
       -0.025641025641025772,
       0.2541666666666667
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 25,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.6097560975609756
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 10,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.24390243902439024
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 6,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.14634146341463414
      }
     },
     "perplexity": {
      "questions": 41,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.6006944444444443,
      "second_median": 0.5238095238095238,
      "difference": 0.07688492063492047,
      "interval_95": [
       -0.06448412698412709,
       0.18426501035196702
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 18,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.43902439024390244
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 23,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.5609756097560976
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 0,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.0
      }
     },
     "claude": {
      "questions": 41,
      "statistic": "difference of the medians",
      "first_median": 0.6909090909090909,
      "second_median": 0.5238095238095238,
      "difference": 0.16709956709956708,
      "interval_95": [
       -0.018939393939393923,
       0.3201754385964913
      ],
      "first_higher": {
       "n": 22,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.5365853658536586
      },
      "first_lower": {
       "n": 19,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.4634146341463415
      },
      "equal": {
       "n": 0,
       "of": 41,
       "share": 0.0
      }
     }
    },
    "answers_with_fewer_readable_pages": {
     "google_aio": {
      "n": 1,
      "of": 41,
      "share": 0.024390243902439025
     },
     "chatgpt": {
      "n": 20,
      "of": 41,
      "share": 0.4878048780487805
     },
     "gemini": {
      "n": 11,
      "of": 41,
      "share": 0.2682926829268293
     },
     "perplexity": {
      "n": 0,
      "of": 41,
      "share": 0.0
     },
     "claude": {
      "n": 1,
      "of": 41,
      "share": 0.024390243902439025
     }
    }
   },
   "share_minus_placebo": {
    "registered_pool": {
     "questions": 41,
     "google_aio": {
      "answers": 41,
      "median": 0.505443239804763,
      "interval_95": [
       0.4382438895489695,
       0.6032353381823392
      ]
     },
     "chatgpt": {
      "answers": 41,
      "median": 0.3755005444066808,
      "interval_95": [
       0.3027350956517389,
       0.49532990157990164
      ]
     },
     "gemini": {
      "answers": 41,
      "median": 0.5919944617119448,
      "interval_95": [
       0.4138205092505348,
       0.6685023215635459
      ]
     },
     "perplexity": {
      "answers": 41,
      "median": 0.5025757058919786,
      "interval_95": [
       0.3799159646117756,
       0.5808820844288112
      ]
     },
     "claude": {
      "answers": 41,
      "median": 0.6660877875525197,
      "interval_95": [
       0.574005379116201,
       0.7017058779385001
      ]
     },
     "intervals": {
      "google_aio and chatgpt": "overlap",
      "google_aio and gemini": "overlap",
      "google_aio and perplexity": "overlap",
      "google_aio and claude": "overlap",
      "chatgpt and gemini": "overlap",
      "chatgpt and perplexity": "overlap",
      "chatgpt and claude": "do not overlap",
      "gemini and perplexity": "overlap",
      "gemini and claude": "overlap",
      "perplexity and claude": "overlap"
     },
     "intervals_against_chatgpt": {
      "google_aio": "overlap",
      "gemini": "overlap",
      "perplexity": "overlap",
      "claude": "do not overlap"
     },
     "paired_against_chatgpt": {
      "google_aio": {
       "questions": 41,
       "statistic": "difference of the medians",
       "first_median": 0.505443239804763,
       "second_median": 0.3755005444066808,
       "difference": 0.12994269539808223,
       "interval_95": [
        -0.013400954935787912,
        0.2758223658633873
       ],
       "first_higher": {
        "n": 23,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.5609756097560976
       },
       "first_lower": {
        "n": 18,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.43902439024390244
       },
       "equal": {
        "n": 0,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.0
       }
      },
      "gemini": {
       "questions": 41,
       "statistic": "difference of the medians",
       "first_median": 0.5919944617119448,
       "second_median": 0.3755005444066808,
       "difference": 0.21649391730526402,
       "interval_95": [
        -0.02311115853771284,
        0.3247302394425039
       ],
       "first_higher": {
        "n": 26,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.6341463414634146
       },
       "first_lower": {
        "n": 14,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.34146341463414637
       },
       "equal": {
        "n": 1,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.024390243902439025
       }
      },
      "perplexity": {
       "questions": 41,
       "statistic": "difference of the medians",
       "first_median": 0.5025757058919786,
       "second_median": 0.3755005444066808,
       "difference": 0.12707516148529785,
       "interval_95": [
        -0.05687380811549708,
        0.24549234584668678
       ],
       "first_higher": {
        "n": 25,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.6097560975609756
       },
       "first_lower": {
        "n": 16,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.3902439024390244
       },
       "equal": {
        "n": 0,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.0
       }
      },
      "claude": {
       "questions": 41,
       "statistic": "difference of the medians",
       "first_median": 0.6660877875525197,
       "second_median": 0.3755005444066808,
       "difference": 0.29058724314583895,
       "interval_95": [
        0.09660368188328594,
        0.38453261025199625
       ],
       "first_higher": {
        "n": 31,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.7560975609756098
       },
       "first_lower": {
        "n": 10,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.24390243902439024
       },
       "equal": {
        "n": 0,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.0
       }
      }
     },
     "median_placebo_per_answer": {
      "google_aio": 0.21769055162851864,
      "chatgpt": 0.15699225387732368,
      "gemini": 0.15409953426798936,
      "perplexity": 0.33923681555195284,
      "claude": 0.19454763660724886
     }
    },
    "added_pool": {
     "questions": 41,
     "google_aio": {
      "answers": 41,
      "median": 0.49574186968622247,
      "interval_95": [
       0.3987098026312751,
       0.5754686630281047
      ]
     },
     "chatgpt": {
      "answers": 41,
      "median": 0.35991711753194433,
      "interval_95": [
       0.2785310131312053,
       0.5059582274989095
      ]
     },
     "gemini": {
      "answers": 41,
      "median": 0.5850291675494055,
      "interval_95": [
       0.40621143873785104,
       0.6395219441854838
      ]
     },
     "perplexity": {
      "answers": 41,
      "median": 0.47416777795462295,
      "interval_95": [
       0.3665290921014517,
       0.5469591875806123
      ]
     },
     "claude": {
      "answers": 41,
      "median": 0.6428341028441077,
      "interval_95": [
       0.5434683211815968,
       0.6819031727587028
      ]
     },
     "intervals": {
      "google_aio and chatgpt": "overlap",
      "google_aio and gemini": "overlap",
      "google_aio and perplexity": "overlap",
      "google_aio and claude": "overlap",
      "chatgpt and gemini": "overlap",
      "chatgpt and perplexity": "overlap",
      "chatgpt and claude": "do not overlap",
      "gemini and perplexity": "overlap",
      "gemini and claude": "overlap",
      "perplexity and claude": "overlap"
     },
     "intervals_against_chatgpt": {
      "google_aio": "overlap",
      "gemini": "overlap",
      "perplexity": "overlap",
      "claude": "do not overlap"
     },
     "paired_against_chatgpt": {
      "google_aio": {
       "questions": 41,
       "statistic": "difference of the medians",
       "first_median": 0.49574186968622247,
       "second_median": 0.35991711753194433,
       "difference": 0.13582475215427814,
       "interval_95": [
        -0.024981041451336783,
        0.2652160944892483
       ],
       "first_higher": {
        "n": 22,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.5365853658536586
       },
       "first_lower": {
        "n": 19,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.4634146341463415
       },
       "equal": {
        "n": 0,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.0
       }
      },
      "gemini": {
       "questions": 41,
       "statistic": "difference of the medians",
       "first_median": 0.5850291675494055,
       "second_median": 0.35991711753194433,
       "difference": 0.22511205001746115,
       "interval_95": [
        -0.024673489821786132,
        0.32958017759147185
       ],
       "first_higher": {
        "n": 26,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.6341463414634146
       },
       "first_lower": {
        "n": 14,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.34146341463414637
       },
       "equal": {
        "n": 1,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.024390243902439025
       }
      },
      "perplexity": {
       "questions": 41,
       "statistic": "difference of the medians",
       "first_median": 0.47416777795462295,
       "second_median": 0.35991711753194433,
       "difference": 0.11425066042267862,
       "interval_95": [
        -0.08411419257411029,
        0.2351570990913165
       ],
       "first_higher": {
        "n": 25,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.6097560975609756
       },
       "first_lower": {
        "n": 16,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.3902439024390244
       },
       "equal": {
        "n": 0,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.0
       }
      },
      "claude": {
       "questions": 41,
       "statistic": "difference of the medians",
       "first_median": 0.6428341028441077,
       "second_median": 0.35991711753194433,
       "difference": 0.28291698531216336,
       "interval_95": [
        0.07132359527141369,
        0.39370305906877123
       ],
       "first_higher": {
        "n": 32,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.7804878048780488
       },
       "first_lower": {
        "n": 9,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.21951219512195122
       },
       "equal": {
        "n": 0,
        "of": 41,
        "share": 0.0
       }
      }
     },
     "median_placebo_per_answer": {
      "google_aio": 0.2481795346025446,
      "chatgpt": 0.17761681773478874,
      "gemini": 0.17273592968320162,
      "perplexity": 0.3711310606744544,
      "claude": 0.21471527689461828
     }
    }
   },
   "both_answers_have_two_or_more_readable_pages": {
    "google_aio": {
     "questions": 20,
     "statistic": "mean of the per-question differences",
     "first_median": 0.880184331797235,
     "second_median": 0.7638888888888888,
     "difference": 0.15170040941604757,
     "interval_95": [
      0.058958402708402705,
      0.2516564919808258
     ],
     "first_higher": {
      "n": 12,
      "of": 20,
      "share": 0.6
     },
     "first_lower": {
      "n": 2,
      "of": 20,
      "share": 0.1
     },
     "equal": {
      "n": 6,
      "of": 20,
      "share": 0.3
     }
    },
    "gemini": {
     "questions": 17,
     "statistic": "mean of the per-question differences",
     "first_median": 0.9117647058823529,
     "second_median": 0.8181818181818182,
     "difference": 0.06572036784677232,
     "interval_95": [
      -0.10342888560881641,
      0.22899298944645877
     ],
     "first_higher": {
      "n": 8,
      "of": 17,
      "share": 0.47058823529411764
     },
     "first_lower": {
      "n": 4,
      "of": 17,
      "share": 0.23529411764705882
     },
     "equal": {
      "n": 5,
      "of": 17,
      "share": 0.29411764705882354
     }
    },
    "perplexity": {
     "questions": 22,
     "statistic": "mean of the per-question differences",
     "first_median": 0.8693181818181819,
     "second_median": 0.7638888888888888,
     "difference": 0.13430204883209998,
     "interval_95": [
      0.04761738348840185,
      0.221491653222646
     ],
     "first_higher": {
      "n": 13,
      "of": 22,
      "share": 0.5909090909090909
     },
     "first_lower": {
      "n": 2,
      "of": 22,
      "share": 0.09090909090909091
     },
     "equal": {
      "n": 7,
      "of": 22,
      "share": 0.3181818181818182
     }
    },
    "claude": {
     "questions": 22,
     "statistic": "mean of the per-question differences",
     "first_median": 0.916083916083916,
     "second_median": 0.7638888888888888,
     "difference": 0.1856136333341986,
     "interval_95": [
      0.08771540866194495,
      0.28781862245691037
     ],
     "first_higher": {
      "n": 14,
      "of": 22,
      "share": 0.6363636363636364
     },
     "first_lower": {
      "n": 3,
      "of": 22,
      "share": 0.13636363636363635
     },
     "equal": {
      "n": 5,
      "of": 22,
      "share": 0.22727272727272727
     }
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "five_engines": {
  "engines": [
   "google_aio",
   "chatgpt",
   "gemini",
   "perplexity",
   "claude"
  ],
  "note": "Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT and Gemini are the engines the preregistration of 5 October 2026 names. Perplexity and Claude were added on 6 October 2026, and their answers went through the same four steps on 7 and 8 October (deviation log, entries 3, 5 and 6).",
  "frame": {
   "answers_collected": {
    "n": 249,
    "of": 250,
    "share": 0.996
   },
   "answers_with_figures": 241,
   "figures": 3465,
   "found": {
    "n": 2693,
    "of": 3465,
    "share": 0.7772005772005772
   },
   "not_found_every_cited_page_readable": 314,
   "first_and_last_answer": {
    "google_aio": [
     "2026-10-05T16:34+03:00",
     "2026-10-07T00:08+03:00"
    ],
    "chatgpt": [
     "2026-10-05T16:53+03:00",
     "2026-10-06T23:21+03:00"
    ],
    "gemini": [
     "2026-10-05T17:08+03:00",
     "2026-10-06T22:34+03:00"
    ],
    "perplexity": [
     "2026-10-06T17:07+03:00",
     "2026-10-06T22:08+03:00"
    ],
    "claude": [
     "2026-10-06T22:39+03:00",
     "2026-10-06T22:44+03:00"
    ]
   }
  },
  "classifier_labels": {
   "absent": 203,
   "partial": 97,
   "rounded": 13,
   "derived": 0,
   "present": 1,
   "unlabelled": 0,
   "absent_quote_unconfirmed": 11,
   "not_found": 314
  },
  "sources": {
   "engines": [
    "google_aio",
    "chatgpt",
    "gemini",
    "perplexity",
    "claude"
   ],
   "answers": 249,
   "answers_with_sources": 239,
   "distinct_pages": 1012,
   "questions_of_the_four_engine_row_that_are_not_in_the_five_engine_row": [
    "TRV-16"
   ],
   "lists_fully_seen": {
    "five_engine_questions": 40,
    "five_engine_questions_with_the_chatgpt_list_fully_seen": 11,
    "five_engine_questions_with_chatgpt_and_gemini_lists_fully_seen": 4
   },
   "without_chatgpt": {
    "engines": [
     "google_aio",
     "gemini",
     "perplexity",
     "claude"
    ],
    "pages": {
     "questions": 45,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.012087313660475446,
     "median_jaccard": 0.0,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 10,
     "pooled_shared": 12,
     "pooled_union": 975
    },
    "ceiling_pages": {
     "questions": 45,
     "mean_shortest_over_longest": 0.23781498813077762,
     "mean_shortest_over_observed_union": 0.12872794242878335,
     "questions_where_the_shortest_list_has_one_source": 6,
     "questions_where_the_engine_has_the_shortest_list": {
      "google_aio": 3,
      "gemini": 42,
      "perplexity": 0,
      "claude": 2
     }
    },
    "domains": {
     "questions": 45,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.02619010619010619,
     "median_jaccard": 0.0,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 15,
     "pooled_shared": 18,
     "pooled_union": 753
    },
    "ceiling_domains": {
     "questions": 45,
     "mean_shortest_over_longest": 0.27972052314157575,
     "mean_shortest_over_observed_union": 0.15999188385669294,
     "questions_where_the_shortest_list_has_one_source": 6,
     "questions_where_the_engine_has_the_shortest_list": {
      "google_aio": 5,
      "gemini": 42,
      "perplexity": 0,
      "claude": 5
     }
    }
   },
   "pages": {
    "questions": 40,
    "mean_jaccard": 0.0026041666666666665,
    "median_jaccard": 0.0,
    "questions_with_a_shared_source": 2,
    "pooled_shared": 2,
    "pooled_union": 925
   },
   "ceiling_pages": {
    "questions": 40,
    "mean_shortest_over_longest": 0.1521155949313844,
    "mean_shortest_over_observed_union": 0.07730891263927882,
    "questions_where_the_shortest_list_has_one_source": 19,
    "questions_where_the_engine_has_the_shortest_list": {
     "google_aio": 0,
     "chatgpt": 35,
     "gemini": 15,
     "perplexity": 0,
     "claude": 0
    }
   },
   "pages_by_engines": {
    "questions": 40,
    "sources_counted_per_question": 925,
    "cited_by_this_many_engines": {
     "1": {
      "n": 733,
      "of": 925,
      "share": 0.7924324324324324
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 135,
      "of": 925,
      "share": 0.14594594594594595
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 40,
      "of": 925,
      "share": 0.043243243243243246
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 15,
      "of": 925,
      "share": 0.016216216216216217
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 2,
      "of": 925,
      "share": 0.002162162162162162
     }
    },
    "questions_where_at_least_this_many_engines_share_a_source": {
     "2": {
      "n": 40,
      "of": 40
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 32,
      "of": 40
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 15,
      "of": 40
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 2,
      "of": 40
     }
    },
    "distinct_sources_over_these_questions": 825
   },
   "pages_without_interrupted_question": {
    "questions": 40,
    "mean_jaccard": 0.0026041666666666665,
    "median_jaccard": 0.0,
    "questions_with_a_shared_source": 2,
    "pooled_shared": 2,
    "pooled_union": 925
   },
   "pages_chatgpt_list_fully_seen": {
    "questions": 11,
    "mean_jaccard": 0.005681818181818182,
    "median_jaccard": 0.0,
    "questions_with_a_shared_source": 1,
    "pooled_shared": 1,
    "pooled_union": 244
   },
   "pairwise_pages": {
    "google_aio+chatgpt": {
     "questions": 42,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.04661405497871663,
     "median_jaccard": 0.0,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 15
    },
    "google_aio+gemini": {
     "questions": 47,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.12071104392756457,
     "median_jaccard": 0.1111111111111111,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 34
    },
    "google_aio+perplexity": {
     "questions": 48,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.1467152018303334,
     "median_jaccard": 0.14285714285714285,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 43
    },
    "google_aio+claude": {
     "questions": 46,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.1444923221138055,
     "median_jaccard": 0.1396103896103896,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 36
    },
    "chatgpt+gemini": {
     "questions": 43,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.029069767441860465,
     "median_jaccard": 0.0,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 4
    },
    "chatgpt+perplexity": {
     "questions": 44,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.03920725738907557,
     "median_jaccard": 0.0,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 18
    },
    "chatgpt+claude": {
     "questions": 43,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.04004245108896272,
     "median_jaccard": 0.0,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 11
    },
    "gemini+perplexity": {
     "questions": 49,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.061767416257212174,
     "median_jaccard": 0.07692307692307693,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 27
    },
    "gemini+claude": {
     "questions": 47,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.10316846274293083,
     "median_jaccard": 0.1111111111111111,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 25
    },
    "perplexity+claude": {
     "questions": 48,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.10838618024586162,
     "median_jaccard": 0.07417582417582418,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 35
    }
   },
   "pairwise_pages_lowest_and_highest_mean": [
    0.029069767441860465,
    0.1467152018303334
   ],
   "domains": {
    "questions": 40,
    "mean_jaccard": 0.009920912420912422,
    "median_jaccard": 0.0,
    "questions_with_a_shared_source": 5,
    "pooled_shared": 5,
    "pooled_union": 694
   },
   "ceiling_domains": {
    "questions": 40,
    "mean_shortest_over_longest": 0.17501250942040417,
    "mean_shortest_over_observed_union": 0.09582466200342933,
    "questions_where_the_shortest_list_has_one_source": 22,
    "questions_where_the_engine_has_the_shortest_list": {
     "google_aio": 1,
     "chatgpt": 36,
     "gemini": 13,
     "perplexity": 0,
     "claude": 0
    }
   },
   "domains_by_engines": {
    "questions": 40,
    "sources_counted_per_question": 694,
    "cited_by_this_many_engines": {
     "1": {
      "n": 487,
      "of": 694,
      "share": 0.7017291066282421
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 132,
      "of": 694,
      "share": 0.19020172910662825
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 45,
      "of": 694,
      "share": 0.06484149855907781
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 25,
      "of": 694,
      "share": 0.03602305475504323
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 5,
      "of": 694,
      "share": 0.007204610951008645
     }
    },
    "questions_where_at_least_this_many_engines_share_a_source": {
     "2": {
      "n": 40,
      "of": 40
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 36,
      "of": 40
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 26,
      "of": 40
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 5,
      "of": 40
     }
    },
    "distinct_sources_over_these_questions": 456
   },
   "domains_without_interrupted_question": {
    "questions": 40,
    "mean_jaccard": 0.009920912420912422,
    "median_jaccard": 0.0,
    "questions_with_a_shared_source": 5,
    "pooled_shared": 5,
    "pooled_union": 694
   },
   "domains_chatgpt_list_fully_seen": {
    "questions": 11,
    "mean_jaccard": 0.008264462809917356,
    "median_jaccard": 0.0,
    "questions_with_a_shared_source": 1,
    "pooled_shared": 1,
    "pooled_union": 198
   },
   "pairwise_domains": {
    "google_aio+chatgpt": {
     "questions": 42,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.14043393775536633,
     "median_jaccard": 0.14285714285714285,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 30
    },
    "google_aio+gemini": {
     "questions": 47,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.17865017057757984,
     "median_jaccard": 0.16666666666666666,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 37
    },
    "google_aio+perplexity": {
     "questions": 48,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.22819398058368645,
     "median_jaccard": 0.21428571428571427,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 45
    },
    "google_aio+claude": {
     "questions": 46,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.2023577157015372,
     "median_jaccard": 0.18181818181818182,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 40
    },
    "chatgpt+gemini": {
     "questions": 43,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.07945736434108527,
     "median_jaccard": 0.0,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 9
    },
    "chatgpt+perplexity": {
     "questions": 44,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.09766558036593921,
     "median_jaccard": 0.1,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 31
    },
    "chatgpt+claude": {
     "questions": 43,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.08667404946474713,
     "median_jaccard": 0.0,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 20
    },
    "gemini+perplexity": {
     "questions": 49,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.08831761177752205,
     "median_jaccard": 0.08333333333333333,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 31
    },
    "gemini+claude": {
     "questions": 47,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.12695035460992907,
     "median_jaccard": 0.1111111111111111,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 26
    },
    "perplexity+claude": {
     "questions": 48,
     "mean_jaccard": 0.1710547039712094,
     "median_jaccard": 0.14835164835164835,
     "questions_with_a_shared_source": 41
    }
   },
   "pairwise_domains_lowest_and_highest_mean": [
    0.07945736434108527,
    0.22819398058368645
   ],
   "most_cited": {
    "distinct_domains": 543,
    "domains_by_engines_reached": {
     "1": 339,
     "2": 115,
     "3": 49,
     "4": 34,
     "5": 6
    },
    "share_cited_by_one_engine_only": 0.6243093922651933,
    "cited_by_every_engine": [
     "bankrate.com",
     "github.blog",
     "kayak.com",
     "samsung.com",
     "tomshardware.com",
     "tsa.gov"
    ],
    "top": [
     {
      "domain": "nerdwallet.com",
      "answers": 37,
      "engines": 4,
      "google_aio": 10,
      "chatgpt": 4,
      "gemini": 0,
      "perplexity": 13,
      "claude": 10
     },
     {
      "domain": "reddit.com",
      "answers": 29,
      "engines": 4,
      "google_aio": 11,
      "chatgpt": 1,
      "gemini": 4,
      "perplexity": 13,
      "claude": 0
     },
     {
      "domain": "youtube.com",
      "answers": 23,
      "engines": 2,
      "google_aio": 21,
      "chatgpt": 0,
      "gemini": 2,
      "perplexity": 0,
      "claude": 0
     },
     {
      "domain": "forbes.com",
      "answers": 15,
      "engines": 2,
      "google_aio": 4,
      "chatgpt": 0,
      "gemini": 0,
      "perplexity": 11,
      "claude": 0
     },
     {
      "domain": "bankrate.com",
      "answers": 14,
      "engines": 5,
      "google_aio": 3,
      "chatgpt": 2,
      "gemini": 3,
      "perplexity": 3,
      "claude": 3
     },
     {
      "domain": "midjourney.com",
      "answers": 13,
      "engines": 4,
      "google_aio": 3,
      "chatgpt": 4,
      "gemini": 0,
      "perplexity": 3,
      "claude": 3
     },
     {
      "domain": "pcmag.com",
      "answers": 13,
      "engines": 3,
      "google_aio": 4,
      "chatgpt": 0,
      "gemini": 4,
      "perplexity": 5,
      "claude": 0
     },
     {
      "domain": "github.com",
      "answers": 12,
      "engines": 4,
      "google_aio": 3,
      "chatgpt": 5,
      "gemini": 1,
      "perplexity": 3,
      "claude": 0
     },
     {
      "domain": "angi.com",
      "answers": 11,
      "engines": 4,
      "google_aio": 4,
      "chatgpt": 1,
      "gemini": 1,
      "perplexity": 0,
      "claude": 5
     },
     {
      "domain": "consumeraffairs.com",
      "answers": 10,
      "engines": 4,
      "google_aio": 2,
      "chatgpt": 0,
      "gemini": 2,
      "perplexity": 2,
      "claude": 4
     },
     {
      "domain": "tsa.gov",
      "answers": 10,
      "engines": 5,
      "google_aio": 3,
      "chatgpt": 1,
      "gemini": 2,
      "perplexity": 3,
      "claude": 1
     },
     {
      "domain": "banani.co",
      "answers": 9,
      "engines": 3,
      "google_aio": 2,
      "chatgpt": 0,
      "gemini": 0,
      "perplexity": 4,
      "claude": 3
     },
     {
      "domain": "eesel.ai",
      "answers": 9,
      "engines": 4,
      "google_aio": 2,
      "chatgpt": 0,
      "gemini": 1,
      "perplexity": 3,
      "claude": 3
     },
     {
      "domain": "experian.com",
      "answers": 9,
      "engines": 4,
      "google_aio": 2,
      "chatgpt": 0,
      "gemini": 3,
      "perplexity": 3,
      "claude": 1
     },
     {
      "domain": "homeguide.com",
      "answers": 9,
      "engines": 4,
      "google_aio": 3,
      "chatgpt": 0,
      "gemini": 1,
      "perplexity": 3,
      "claude": 2
     },
     {
      "domain": "costbench.com",
      "answers": 8,
      "engines": 2,
      "google_aio": 0,
      "chatgpt": 0,
      "gemini": 0,
      "perplexity": 7,
      "claude": 1
     },
     {
      "domain": "extraspace.com",
      "answers": 8,
      "engines": 4,
      "google_aio": 3,
      "chatgpt": 0,
      "gemini": 2,
      "perplexity": 2,
      "claude": 1
     },
     {
      "domain": "kayak.com",
      "answers": 8,
      "engines": 5,
      "google_aio": 2,
      "chatgpt": 1,
      "gemini": 1,
      "perplexity": 2,
      "claude": 2
     },
     {
      "domain": "yahoo.com",
      "answers": 8,
      "engines": 3,
      "google_aio": 2,
      "chatgpt": 0,
      "gemini": 0,
      "perplexity": 4,
      "claude": 2
     },
     {
      "domain": "bestbuy.com",
      "answers": 7,
      "engines": 4,
      "google_aio": 1,
      "chatgpt": 1,
      "gemini": 0,
      "perplexity": 4,
      "claude": 1
     }
    ]
   }
  }
 }
}