{
 "title": "Figures written as a range and figures written as a single value",
 "status": "Exploratory view added after publication, outside the preregistration (deviation log, entry 8). Not part of deposit version 1.0.0 of doi:10.5281/zenodo.23238429.",
 "engines": {
  "google_aio": {
   "label": "Google AI Overviews",
   "figures": 640,
   "all_figures_found": {
    "n": 507,
    "of": 640,
    "share": 0.7922
   },
   "ranges_share_of_all_figures": {
    "n": 245,
    "of": 640,
    "share": 0.3828
   },
   "single": {
    "figures": 394,
    "found": {
     "n": 357,
     "of": 394,
     "share": 0.9061
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 14,
     "of": 394,
     "share": 0.0355
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 23,
     "of": 394,
     "share": 0.0584
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 19,
     "found_attached": 142,
     "found_elsewhere": 215,
     "no_source": 4,
     "not_found": 14
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 14
    },
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range": {
    "figures": 245,
    "found": {
     "n": 150,
     "of": 245,
     "share": 0.6122
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 20,
     "of": 245,
     "share": 0.0816
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 75,
     "of": 245,
     "share": 0.3061
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 64,
     "found_attached": 60,
     "found_elsewhere": 90,
     "no_source": 11,
     "not_found": 20
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 4,
     "partial": 15,
     "rounded": 1
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 11,
     "one_part_rounded": 1,
     "other_qualifier": 3
    }
   },
   "not_read": {
    "figures": 1,
    "found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 1,
     "share": null
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 1,
     "share": null
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 1,
     "of": 1,
     "share": null
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "instrument_gap": 1
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "not_read_kind_range": 1,
   "single_including_not_read": {
    "figures": 395,
    "found": {
     "n": 357,
     "of": 395,
     "share": 0.9038
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 14,
     "of": 395,
     "share": 0.0354
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 24,
     "of": 395,
     "share": 0.0608
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 19,
     "found_attached": 142,
     "found_elsewhere": 215,
     "instrument_gap": 1,
     "no_source": 4,
     "not_found": 14
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 14
    },
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range_strict": {
    "figures": 235,
    "found": {
     "n": 143,
     "of": 235,
     "share": 0.6085
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 20,
     "of": 235,
     "share": 0.0851
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 72,
     "of": 235,
     "share": 0.3064
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 64,
     "found_attached": 53,
     "found_elsewhere": 90,
     "no_source": 8,
     "not_found": 20
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 4,
     "partial": 15,
     "rounded": 1
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 11,
     "one_part_rounded": 1,
     "other_qualifier": 3
    }
   },
   "range_other_join": {
    "figures": 10,
    "found": {
     "n": 7,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.7
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 3,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.3
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "found_attached": 7,
     "no_source": 3
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range_by_kind": {
    "figures": 241,
    "found": {
     "n": 146,
     "of": 241,
     "share": 0.6058
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 20,
     "of": 241,
     "share": 0.083
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 75,
     "of": 241,
     "share": 0.3112
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 64,
     "found_attached": 56,
     "found_elsewhere": 90,
     "no_source": 11,
     "not_found": 20
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 4,
     "partial": 15,
     "rounded": 1
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 11,
     "one_part_rounded": 1,
     "other_qualifier": 3
    }
   },
   "range_not_by_kind": {
    "figures": 4,
    "found": {
     "n": 4,
     "of": 4,
     "share": null
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 4,
     "share": null
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 4,
     "share": null
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "found_attached": 4
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "not_found_that_are_ranges": {
    "n": 20,
    "of": 34,
    "share": 0.5882
   },
   "all_readable": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 268,
     "of": 302,
     "share": 0.8874
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 200,
     "of": 214,
     "share": 0.9346
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 68,
     "of": 88,
     "share": 0.7727
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 355,
     "of": 473,
     "share": 0.7505
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 236,
     "of": 265,
     "share": 0.8906
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 119,
     "of": 208,
     "share": 0.5721
    },
    "ranges_without_unit": 37
   },
   "single_minus_range_interval": {
    "questions": 47,
    "resamples": 10000,
    "used": 10000,
    "seed": 1109872877,
    "low_points": 17.7,
    "high_points": 42.9
   }
  },
  "chatgpt": {
   "label": "ChatGPT",
   "figures": 470,
   "all_figures_found": {
    "n": 267,
    "of": 470,
    "share": 0.5681
   },
   "ranges_share_of_all_figures": {
    "n": 138,
    "of": 470,
    "share": 0.2936
   },
   "single": {
    "figures": 332,
    "found": {
     "n": 239,
     "of": 332,
     "share": 0.7199
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 34,
     "of": 332,
     "share": 0.1024
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 59,
     "of": 332,
     "share": 0.1777
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 45,
     "found_attached": 113,
     "found_elsewhere": 126,
     "no_source": 14,
     "not_found": 34
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 30,
     "partial": 2,
     "rounded": 2
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "range": {
    "figures": 138,
    "found": {
     "n": 28,
     "of": 138,
     "share": 0.2029
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 75,
     "of": 138,
     "share": 0.5435
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 35,
     "of": 138,
     "share": 0.2536
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 21,
     "found_attached": 14,
     "found_elsewhere": 14,
     "no_source": 14,
     "not_found": 75
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 56,
     "partial": 19
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 4,
     "one_part_rounded": 10,
     "other_qualifier": 5
    }
   },
   "not_read": {
    "figures": 0,
    "found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 0,
     "share": null
    },
    "outcomes": {},
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "not_read_kind_range": 0,
   "single_including_not_read": {
    "figures": 332,
    "found": {
     "n": 239,
     "of": 332,
     "share": 0.7199
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 34,
     "of": 332,
     "share": 0.1024
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 59,
     "of": 332,
     "share": 0.1777
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 45,
     "found_attached": 113,
     "found_elsewhere": 126,
     "no_source": 14,
     "not_found": 34
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 30,
     "partial": 2,
     "rounded": 2
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "range_strict": {
    "figures": 128,
    "found": {
     "n": 24,
     "of": 128,
     "share": 0.1875
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 71,
     "of": 128,
     "share": 0.5547
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 33,
     "of": 128,
     "share": 0.2578
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 19,
     "found_attached": 14,
     "found_elsewhere": 10,
     "no_source": 14,
     "not_found": 71
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 54,
     "partial": 17
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 4,
     "one_part_rounded": 10,
     "other_qualifier": 3
    }
   },
   "range_other_join": {
    "figures": 10,
    "found": {
     "n": 4,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.4
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 4,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.4
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.2
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 2,
     "found_elsewhere": 4,
     "not_found": 4
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 2,
     "partial": 2
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "range_by_kind": {
    "figures": 128,
    "found": {
     "n": 24,
     "of": 128,
     "share": 0.1875
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 71,
     "of": 128,
     "share": 0.5547
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 33,
     "of": 128,
     "share": 0.2578
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 19,
     "found_attached": 14,
     "found_elsewhere": 10,
     "no_source": 14,
     "not_found": 71
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 54,
     "partial": 17
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 4,
     "one_part_rounded": 10,
     "other_qualifier": 3
    }
   },
   "range_not_by_kind": {
    "figures": 10,
    "found": {
     "n": 4,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.4
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 4,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.4
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.2
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 2,
     "found_elsewhere": 4,
     "not_found": 4
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 2,
     "partial": 2
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "not_found_that_are_ranges": {
    "n": 75,
    "of": 109,
    "share": 0.6881
   },
   "all_readable": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 217,
     "of": 326,
     "share": 0.6656
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 203,
     "of": 237,
     "share": 0.8565
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 14,
     "of": 89,
     "share": 0.1573
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 186,
     "of": 365,
     "share": 0.5096
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 166,
     "of": 248,
     "share": 0.6694
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 20,
     "of": 117,
     "share": 0.1709
    },
    "ranges_without_unit": 21
   },
   "single_minus_range_interval": {
    "questions": 47,
    "resamples": 10000,
    "used": 10000,
    "seed": 1109872877,
    "low_points": 34.9,
    "high_points": 66.2
   }
  },
  "gemini": {
   "label": "Gemini",
   "figures": 661,
   "all_figures_found": {
    "n": 453,
    "of": 661,
    "share": 0.6853
   },
   "ranges_share_of_all_figures": {
    "n": 304,
    "of": 661,
    "share": 0.4599
   },
   "single": {
    "figures": 352,
    "found": {
     "n": 290,
     "of": 352,
     "share": 0.8239
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 30,
     "of": 352,
     "share": 0.0852
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 32,
     "of": 352,
     "share": 0.0909
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 22,
     "found_attached": 191,
     "found_elsewhere": 99,
     "no_source": 10,
     "not_found": 30
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 30
    },
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range": {
    "figures": 304,
    "found": {
     "n": 163,
     "of": 304,
     "share": 0.5362
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 107,
     "of": 304,
     "share": 0.352
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 34,
     "of": 304,
     "share": 0.1118
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 34,
     "found_attached": 90,
     "found_elsewhere": 73,
     "not_found": 107
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 50,
     "partial": 51,
     "present": 1,
     "rounded": 5
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 24,
     "one_part_rounded": 19,
     "other_qualifier": 8
    }
   },
   "not_read": {
    "figures": 5,
    "found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 5,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 5,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 5,
     "of": 5,
     "share": 1.0
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "instrument_gap": 5
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "not_read_kind_range": 3,
   "single_including_not_read": {
    "figures": 357,
    "found": {
     "n": 290,
     "of": 357,
     "share": 0.8123
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 30,
     "of": 357,
     "share": 0.084
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 37,
     "of": 357,
     "share": 0.1036
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 22,
     "found_attached": 191,
     "found_elsewhere": 99,
     "instrument_gap": 5,
     "no_source": 10,
     "not_found": 30
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 30
    },
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range_strict": {
    "figures": 288,
    "found": {
     "n": 155,
     "of": 288,
     "share": 0.5382
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 103,
     "of": 288,
     "share": 0.3576
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 30,
     "of": 288,
     "share": 0.1042
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 30,
     "found_attached": 84,
     "found_elsewhere": 71,
     "not_found": 103
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 47,
     "partial": 51,
     "rounded": 5
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 24,
     "one_part_rounded": 19,
     "other_qualifier": 8
    }
   },
   "range_other_join": {
    "figures": 16,
    "found": {
     "n": 8,
     "of": 16,
     "share": 0.5
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 4,
     "of": 16,
     "share": 0.25
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 4,
     "of": 16,
     "share": 0.25
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 4,
     "found_attached": 6,
     "found_elsewhere": 2,
     "not_found": 4
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 3,
     "present": 1
    },
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range_by_kind": {
    "figures": 298,
    "found": {
     "n": 159,
     "of": 298,
     "share": 0.5336
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 105,
     "of": 298,
     "share": 0.3523
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 34,
     "of": 298,
     "share": 0.1141
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 34,
     "found_attached": 88,
     "found_elsewhere": 71,
     "not_found": 105
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 49,
     "partial": 51,
     "rounded": 5
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 24,
     "one_part_rounded": 19,
     "other_qualifier": 8
    }
   },
   "range_not_by_kind": {
    "figures": 6,
    "found": {
     "n": 4,
     "of": 6,
     "share": 0.6667
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 6,
     "share": 0.3333
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 6,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "found_attached": 2,
     "found_elsewhere": 2,
     "not_found": 2
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 1,
     "present": 1
    },
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "not_found_that_are_ranges": {
    "n": 107,
    "of": 137,
    "share": 0.781
   },
   "all_readable": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 347,
     "of": 489,
     "share": 0.7096
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 221,
     "of": 251,
     "share": 0.8805
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 126,
     "of": 233,
     "share": 0.5408
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 312,
     "of": 475,
     "share": 0.6568
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 186,
     "of": 220,
     "share": 0.8455
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 126,
     "of": 255,
     "share": 0.4941
    },
    "ranges_without_unit": 49
   },
   "single_minus_range_interval": {
    "questions": 50,
    "resamples": 10000,
    "used": 10000,
    "seed": 1109872877,
    "low_points": 13.6,
    "high_points": 44.0
   }
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "label": "Perplexity",
   "figures": 755,
   "all_figures_found": {
    "n": 644,
    "of": 755,
    "share": 0.853
   },
   "ranges_share_of_all_figures": {
    "n": 163,
    "of": 755,
    "share": 0.2159
   },
   "single": {
    "figures": 590,
    "found": {
     "n": 510,
     "of": 590,
     "share": 0.8644
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 590,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 80,
     "of": 590,
     "share": 0.1356
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 80,
     "found_elsewhere": 510
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range": {
    "figures": 163,
    "found": {
     "n": 134,
     "of": 163,
     "share": 0.8221
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 163,
     "share": 0.0123
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 27,
     "of": 163,
     "share": 0.1656
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 27,
     "found_elsewhere": 134,
     "not_found": 2
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "partial": 2
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 2
    }
   },
   "not_read": {
    "figures": 2,
    "found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 2,
     "share": null
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 2,
     "share": null
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 2,
     "share": null
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "instrument_gap": 2
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "not_read_kind_range": 0,
   "single_including_not_read": {
    "figures": 592,
    "found": {
     "n": 510,
     "of": 592,
     "share": 0.8615
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 592,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 82,
     "of": 592,
     "share": 0.1385
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 80,
     "found_elsewhere": 510,
     "instrument_gap": 2
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range_strict": {
    "figures": 158,
    "found": {
     "n": 129,
     "of": 158,
     "share": 0.8165
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 158,
     "share": 0.0127
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 27,
     "of": 158,
     "share": 0.1709
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 27,
     "found_elsewhere": 129,
     "not_found": 2
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "partial": 2
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 2
    }
   },
   "range_other_join": {
    "figures": 5,
    "found": {
     "n": 5,
     "of": 5,
     "share": 1.0
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 5,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 5,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "found_elsewhere": 5
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range_by_kind": {
    "figures": 159,
    "found": {
     "n": 130,
     "of": 159,
     "share": 0.8176
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 159,
     "share": 0.0126
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 27,
     "of": 159,
     "share": 0.1698
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 27,
     "found_elsewhere": 130,
     "not_found": 2
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "partial": 2
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 2
    }
   },
   "range_not_by_kind": {
    "figures": 4,
    "found": {
     "n": 4,
     "of": 4,
     "share": null
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 4,
     "share": null
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 4,
     "share": null
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "found_elsewhere": 4
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "not_found_that_are_ranges": {
    "n": 2,
    "of": 2,
    "share": null
   },
   "all_readable": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 61,
     "of": 63,
     "share": 0.9683
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 49,
     "of": 49,
     "share": 1.0
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 12,
     "of": 14,
     "share": 0.8571
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 467,
     "of": 576,
     "share": 0.8108
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 352,
     "of": 432,
     "share": 0.8148
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 115,
     "of": 144,
     "share": 0.7986
    },
    "ranges_without_unit": 19
   },
   "single_minus_range_interval": {
    "questions": 47,
    "resamples": 10000,
    "used": 10000,
    "seed": 1109872877,
    "low_points": -6.2,
    "high_points": 14.5
   }
  },
  "claude": {
   "label": "Claude (API)",
   "figures": 939,
   "all_figures_found": {
    "n": 822,
    "of": 939,
    "share": 0.8754
   },
   "ranges_share_of_all_figures": {
    "n": 294,
    "of": 939,
    "share": 0.3131
   },
   "single": {
    "figures": 644,
    "found": {
     "n": 583,
     "of": 644,
     "share": 0.9053
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 13,
     "of": 644,
     "share": 0.0202
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 48,
     "of": 644,
     "share": 0.0745
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 42,
     "found_attached": 413,
     "found_elsewhere": 170,
     "no_source": 6,
     "not_found": 13
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 12,
     "rounded": 1
    },
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range": {
    "figures": 294,
    "found": {
     "n": 239,
     "of": 294,
     "share": 0.8129
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 19,
     "of": 294,
     "share": 0.0646
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 36,
     "of": 294,
     "share": 0.1224
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 29,
     "found_attached": 161,
     "found_elsewhere": 78,
     "no_source": 7,
     "not_found": 19
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 7,
     "partial": 8,
     "rounded": 4
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 4,
     "one_part_rounded": 1,
     "other_qualifier": 3
    }
   },
   "not_read": {
    "figures": 1,
    "found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 1,
     "share": null
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 1,
     "share": null
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 1,
     "of": 1,
     "share": null
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "instrument_gap": 1
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "not_read_kind_range": 1,
   "single_including_not_read": {
    "figures": 645,
    "found": {
     "n": 583,
     "of": 645,
     "share": 0.9039
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 13,
     "of": 645,
     "share": 0.0202
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 49,
     "of": 645,
     "share": 0.076
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 42,
     "found_attached": 413,
     "found_elsewhere": 170,
     "instrument_gap": 1,
     "no_source": 6,
     "not_found": 13
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 12,
     "rounded": 1
    },
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range_strict": {
    "figures": 284,
    "found": {
     "n": 231,
     "of": 284,
     "share": 0.8134
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 19,
     "of": 284,
     "share": 0.0669
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 34,
     "of": 284,
     "share": 0.1197
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 28,
     "found_attached": 153,
     "found_elsewhere": 78,
     "no_source": 6,
     "not_found": 19
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 7,
     "partial": 8,
     "rounded": 4
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 4,
     "one_part_rounded": 1,
     "other_qualifier": 3
    }
   },
   "range_other_join": {
    "figures": 10,
    "found": {
     "n": 8,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.8
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 10,
     "share": 0.2
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 1,
     "found_attached": 8,
     "no_source": 1
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "range_by_kind": {
    "figures": 285,
    "found": {
     "n": 231,
     "of": 285,
     "share": 0.8105
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 19,
     "of": 285,
     "share": 0.0667
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 35,
     "of": 285,
     "share": 0.1228
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 28,
     "found_attached": 153,
     "found_elsewhere": 78,
     "no_source": 7,
     "not_found": 19
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 7,
     "partial": 8,
     "rounded": 4
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 4,
     "one_part_rounded": 1,
     "other_qualifier": 3
    }
   },
   "range_not_by_kind": {
    "figures": 9,
    "found": {
     "n": 8,
     "of": 9,
     "share": 0.8889
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 9,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 1,
     "of": 9,
     "share": 0.1111
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 1,
     "found_attached": 8
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "not_found_that_are_ranges": {
    "n": 19,
    "of": 32,
    "share": 0.5938
   },
   "all_readable": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 397,
     "of": 430,
     "share": 0.9233
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 275,
     "of": 288,
     "share": 0.9549
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 122,
     "of": 141,
     "share": 0.8652
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 678,
     "of": 775,
     "share": 0.8748
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 468,
     "of": 523,
     "share": 0.8948
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 210,
     "of": 252,
     "share": 0.8333
    },
    "ranges_without_unit": 42
   },
   "single_minus_range_interval": {
    "questions": 50,
    "resamples": 10000,
    "used": 10000,
    "seed": 1109872877,
    "low_points": 2.2,
    "high_points": 18.0
   }
  }
 },
 "pooled": {
  "registered_three": {
   "label": "Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT and Gemini",
   "engines": [
    "google_aio",
    "chatgpt",
    "gemini"
   ],
   "figures": 1771,
   "all_figures_found": {
    "n": 1227,
    "of": 1771,
    "share": 0.6928
   },
   "ranges_share_of_all_figures": {
    "n": 687,
    "of": 1771,
    "share": 0.3879
   },
   "single": {
    "figures": 1078,
    "found": {
     "n": 886,
     "of": 1078,
     "share": 0.8219
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 78,
     "of": 1078,
     "share": 0.0724
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 114,
     "of": 1078,
     "share": 0.1058
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 86,
     "found_attached": 446,
     "found_elsewhere": 440,
     "no_source": 28,
     "not_found": 78
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 74,
     "partial": 2,
     "rounded": 2
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "range": {
    "figures": 687,
    "found": {
     "n": 341,
     "of": 687,
     "share": 0.4964
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 202,
     "of": 687,
     "share": 0.294
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 144,
     "of": 687,
     "share": 0.2096
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 119,
     "found_attached": 164,
     "found_elsewhere": 177,
     "no_source": 25,
     "not_found": 202
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 110,
     "partial": 85,
     "present": 1,
     "rounded": 6
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 39,
     "one_part_rounded": 30,
     "other_qualifier": 16
    }
   },
   "not_read": {
    "figures": 6,
    "found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 6,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 6,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 6,
     "of": 6,
     "share": 1.0
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "instrument_gap": 6
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "not_read_kind_range": 4,
   "single_including_not_read": {
    "figures": 1084,
    "found": {
     "n": 886,
     "of": 1084,
     "share": 0.8173
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 78,
     "of": 1084,
     "share": 0.072
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 120,
     "of": 1084,
     "share": 0.1107
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 86,
     "found_attached": 446,
     "found_elsewhere": 440,
     "instrument_gap": 6,
     "no_source": 28,
     "not_found": 78
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 74,
     "partial": 2,
     "rounded": 2
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "range_strict": {
    "figures": 651,
    "found": {
     "n": 322,
     "of": 651,
     "share": 0.4946
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 194,
     "of": 651,
     "share": 0.298
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 135,
     "of": 651,
     "share": 0.2074
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 113,
     "found_attached": 151,
     "found_elsewhere": 171,
     "no_source": 22,
     "not_found": 194
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 105,
     "partial": 83,
     "rounded": 6
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 39,
     "one_part_rounded": 30,
     "other_qualifier": 14
    }
   },
   "range_other_join": {
    "figures": 36,
    "found": {
     "n": 19,
     "of": 36,
     "share": 0.5278
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 8,
     "of": 36,
     "share": 0.2222
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 9,
     "of": 36,
     "share": 0.25
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 6,
     "found_attached": 13,
     "found_elsewhere": 6,
     "no_source": 3,
     "not_found": 8
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 5,
     "partial": 2,
     "present": 1
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "range_by_kind": {
    "figures": 667,
    "found": {
     "n": 329,
     "of": 667,
     "share": 0.4933
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 196,
     "of": 667,
     "share": 0.2939
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 142,
     "of": 667,
     "share": 0.2129
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 117,
     "found_attached": 158,
     "found_elsewhere": 171,
     "no_source": 25,
     "not_found": 196
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 107,
     "partial": 83,
     "rounded": 6
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 39,
     "one_part_rounded": 30,
     "other_qualifier": 14
    }
   },
   "range_not_by_kind": {
    "figures": 20,
    "found": {
     "n": 12,
     "of": 20,
     "share": 0.6
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 6,
     "of": 20,
     "share": 0.3
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 2,
     "of": 20,
     "share": 0.1
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 2,
     "found_attached": 6,
     "found_elsewhere": 6,
     "not_found": 6
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 3,
     "partial": 2,
     "present": 1
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "not_found_that_are_ranges": {
    "n": 202,
    "of": 280,
    "share": 0.7214
   },
   "all_readable": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 832,
     "of": 1117,
     "share": 0.7449
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 624,
     "of": 702,
     "share": 0.8889
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 208,
     "of": 410,
     "share": 0.5073
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 853,
     "of": 1313,
     "share": 0.6497
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 588,
     "of": 733,
     "share": 0.8022
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 265,
     "of": 580,
     "share": 0.4569
    },
    "ranges_without_unit": 107
   },
   "single_minus_range_interval": {
    "questions": 50,
    "resamples": 10000,
    "used": 10000,
    "seed": 1109872877,
    "low_points": 20.8,
    "high_points": 43.7
   }
  },
  "all_five": {
   "label": "All five engines",
   "engines": [
    "google_aio",
    "chatgpt",
    "gemini",
    "perplexity",
    "claude"
   ],
   "figures": 3465,
   "all_figures_found": {
    "n": 2693,
    "of": 3465,
    "share": 0.7772
   },
   "ranges_share_of_all_figures": {
    "n": 1144,
    "of": 3465,
    "share": 0.3302
   },
   "single": {
    "figures": 2312,
    "found": {
     "n": 1979,
     "of": 2312,
     "share": 0.856
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 91,
     "of": 2312,
     "share": 0.0394
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 242,
     "of": 2312,
     "share": 0.1047
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 208,
     "found_attached": 859,
     "found_elsewhere": 1120,
     "no_source": 34,
     "not_found": 91
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 86,
     "partial": 2,
     "rounded": 3
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "range": {
    "figures": 1144,
    "found": {
     "n": 714,
     "of": 1144,
     "share": 0.6241
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 223,
     "of": 1144,
     "share": 0.1949
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 207,
     "of": 1144,
     "share": 0.1809
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 175,
     "found_attached": 325,
     "found_elsewhere": 389,
     "no_source": 32,
     "not_found": 223
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 117,
     "partial": 95,
     "present": 1,
     "rounded": 10
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 45,
     "one_part_rounded": 31,
     "other_qualifier": 19
    }
   },
   "not_read": {
    "figures": 9,
    "found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 9,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 0,
     "of": 9,
     "share": 0.0
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 9,
     "of": 9,
     "share": 1.0
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "instrument_gap": 9
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {},
    "partial_cases": {}
   },
   "not_read_kind_range": 5,
   "single_including_not_read": {
    "figures": 2321,
    "found": {
     "n": 1979,
     "of": 2321,
     "share": 0.8526
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 91,
     "of": 2321,
     "share": 0.0392
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 251,
     "of": 2321,
     "share": 0.1081
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 208,
     "found_attached": 859,
     "found_elsewhere": 1120,
     "instrument_gap": 9,
     "no_source": 34,
     "not_found": 91
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 86,
     "partial": 2,
     "rounded": 3
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "range_strict": {
    "figures": 1093,
    "found": {
     "n": 682,
     "of": 1093,
     "share": 0.624
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 215,
     "of": 1093,
     "share": 0.1967
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 196,
     "of": 1093,
     "share": 0.1793
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 168,
     "found_attached": 304,
     "found_elsewhere": 378,
     "no_source": 28,
     "not_found": 215
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 112,
     "partial": 93,
     "rounded": 10
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 45,
     "one_part_rounded": 31,
     "other_qualifier": 17
    }
   },
   "range_other_join": {
    "figures": 51,
    "found": {
     "n": 32,
     "of": 51,
     "share": 0.6275
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 8,
     "of": 51,
     "share": 0.1569
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 11,
     "of": 51,
     "share": 0.2157
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 7,
     "found_attached": 21,
     "found_elsewhere": 11,
     "no_source": 4,
     "not_found": 8
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 5,
     "partial": 2,
     "present": 1
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "range_by_kind": {
    "figures": 1111,
    "found": {
     "n": 690,
     "of": 1111,
     "share": 0.6211
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 217,
     "of": 1111,
     "share": 0.1953
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 204,
     "of": 1111,
     "share": 0.1836
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 172,
     "found_attached": 311,
     "found_elsewhere": 379,
     "no_source": 32,
     "not_found": 217
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 114,
     "partial": 93,
     "rounded": 10
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "one_part_exact": 45,
     "one_part_rounded": 31,
     "other_qualifier": 17
    }
   },
   "range_not_by_kind": {
    "figures": 33,
    "found": {
     "n": 24,
     "of": 33,
     "share": 0.7273
    },
    "not_found": {
     "n": 6,
     "of": 33,
     "share": 0.1818
    },
    "unknown": {
     "n": 3,
     "of": 33,
     "share": 0.0909
    },
    "outcomes": {
     "access_failure": 3,
     "found_attached": 14,
     "found_elsewhere": 10,
     "not_found": 6
    },
    "classifier_labels_of_not_found": {
     "absent": 3,
     "partial": 2,
     "present": 1
    },
    "partial_cases": {
     "other_qualifier": 2
    }
   },
   "not_found_that_are_ranges": {
    "n": 223,
    "of": 314,
    "share": 0.7102
   },
   "all_readable": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 1290,
     "of": 1610,
     "share": 0.8012
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 948,
     "of": 1039,
     "share": 0.9124
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 342,
     "of": 565,
     "share": 0.6053
    }
   },
   "with_unit": {
    "figures_found": {
     "n": 1998,
     "of": 2664,
     "share": 0.75
    },
    "single_found": {
     "n": 1408,
     "of": 1688,
     "share": 0.8341
    },
    "range_found": {
     "n": 590,
     "of": 976,
     "share": 0.6045
    },
    "ranges_without_unit": 168
   },
   "single_minus_range_interval": {
    "questions": 50,
    "resamples": 10000,
    "used": 10000,
    "seed": 1109872877,
    "low_points": 15.2,
    "high_points": 31.3
   }
  }
 },
 "rule": {
  "single": "exactly 1 component in the check output",
  "range": "2 or more components in the check output",
  "not_read": "0 components: instrument gap, the extractor's figure is not in its sentence",
  "range_strict": "a range whose adjacent parts are all joined by RANGE_SEP of check_figures.py",
  "range_by_kind": "a range whose extractor field kind is 'range'",
  "single_including_not_read": "every figure with fewer than 2 components (the convention of the reply of 16 October 2026)",
  "all_readable": "cited_pages > 0, readable_pages == cited_pages, pages_without_address == 0",
  "with_unit": "at least one component carries a unit sign",
  "partial_cases": "other_qualifier: the page's figure carries another qualifier; one_part_exact: at least one part equals the page's figure; one_part_rounded: the parts that fit do so only within rounding (method note, section 8)",
  "outcomes": {
   "found_attached": "found",
   "found_elsewhere": "found",
   "not_found": "not_found",
   "no_source": "unknown",
   "access_failure": "unknown",
   "instrument_gap": "unknown"
  },
  "denominator": "every figure of the group",
  "small_cells": "no share for a cell of fewer than 5 units",
  "interval": "95% percentile bootstrap of single minus range in points, pooled shares, resampling questions with replacement",
  "asserted_against": {
   "table 3": {
    "google_aio": [
     640,
     507
    ],
    "chatgpt": [
     470,
     267
    ],
    "gemini": [
     661,
     453
    ],
    "perplexity": [
     755,
     644
    ],
    "claude": [
     939,
     822
    ]
   },
   "table 4": {
    "google_aio": [
     302,
     268
    ],
    "chatgpt": [
     326,
     217
    ],
    "gemini": [
     489,
     347
    ],
    "perplexity": [
     63,
     61
    ],
    "claude": [
     430,
     397
    ]
   },
   "table S4": {
    "google_aio": [
     473,
     355
    ],
    "chatgpt": [
     365,
     186
    ],
    "gemini": [
     475,
     312
    ],
    "perplexity": [
     576,
     467
    ],
    "claude": [
     775,
     678
    ]
   }
  }
 },
 "inputs": {
  "deposit": "doi:10.5281/zenodo.23238429",
  "files": 498,
  "sha256_of_sorted_list": "fd5855745d7f4302b48beb2e4769d77b989a85b668e2c987ecda959da214e43d",
  "checked_against_manifest": true
 }
}
